National organizations such as pediatricians healthcare professional They argue that “gender-affirming” therapy has not been shown to benefit young people with gender dysphoria.
The Florida-based American College of Pediatricians (ACPeds) stated on February 7th, “Social transition, puberty blockers, and cross-sex hormones have no demonstrable long-term benefit for children’s psychosocial well-being.” “This will not result in any negative impact,” the statement said. young people with gender dysphoria. ”
“A review of at least 60 research papers demonstrates that social affirmation, puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, or surgical intervention are not beneficial for these youth,” said lead author and associate of ACPeds. Chairman Dr. Jane Anderson wrote in an email to Fox. News Digital.
British study finds that transgender children who take puberty blocking drugs have mental health problems
All 60 studies reviewed focused on the mental health of young people suffering from gender dysphoria.
The position statement was voted on and passed by ACPeds’ board and members, a spokesperson told Fox News Digital.
A national organization of pediatricians and other medical professionals maintains that “gender-affirming” therapy has not been shown to benefit youth with gender dysphoria. (St. Petersburg)
In a fact sheet summarizing the findings, ACPeds states that “young people whose perceived gender identity does not match their biological sex… mental health problems regardless of their affirmation of gender identity. ”
Young people who identify as “gender nonconforming” often have mental illnesses such as depression and anxiety, Anderson said.
Exposing the transgender agenda for our children: Faith leaders reveal how parents can keep their children safe
ACPeds also said that more than half of LGBTQ+ sexual minorities have experienced “adverse childhood experiences,” including child abuse.
According to the data, transgender youth reported the highest levels of abuse and neglect.
The researchers said their review “casts doubt on the claim that social affirmation (such as the use of preferred pronouns) of young people who identify as transgender helps their long-term development.” Ta. psychosocial well-being. ”
Researchers have found that the use of puberty blockers (drugs that delay puberty in children) does not provide significant benefit for young people experiencing gender dysphoria. (St. Petersburg)
“Adolescents’ brains are immature and should not be allowed to make lifelong decisions such as: decreased fertilitywhen they were very young,” Anderson told FOX News Digital.
As for specific treatments, researchers found that the use of puberty blockers (drugs that delay puberty in children) did not provide significant benefit for young people experiencing gender dysphoria.
“Adolescents’ brains are immature and they should not make lifelong decisions, such as reducing their fertility, at a young age.”
“the study [that] A study that purported to show a reduction in “lifelong suicidal ideation” in people who received puberty blockers actually showed a decrease in the number of participants who received the blockers who wished they had just taken the blockers. “In comparison, serious suicide attempts were twice as common,” the study’s fact sheet states.
Cross-sex hormonal interventions (treatments that induce a transition to the desired gender) have also been shown to have “little mental health benefit” and are even associated with an increased need for psychiatric treatment, ACPed. said.
Data shows that the majority of adolescents with gender dysphoria eventually identify with their birth gender, meaning that treatment may prove unnecessary in such cases. Then the doctor said. (St. Petersburg)
The review also found that many teens who seek gender-affirming therapy, whether surgical or hormonal, end up reverting to their biological sex.
“There are people right now who are expressing regret about their transition,” Anderson told FOX News Digital.
Doctors react to report
Dr. Brett Osborne, a neurologist and longevity expert in Florida who was not involved in this analysis, shared his thoughts on the topic, saying that the topic “is often influenced by political bias or religious background. “It’s often provoked,” he said.
“I agree with the ACPeds position statement,” he told Fox News Digital. “This means that a holistic approach with strong psychiatric interventions should be adopted before gender-altering treatments.”
Surfer Bethany Hamilton speaks out against new rules allowing transgender women to compete against women
Data shows that the majority of adolescents with gender dysphoria eventually identify with their birth gender, meaning that treatment may prove unnecessary in such cases. the doctor pointed out.
“Medical professionals should primarily seek to address gender dysphoria through a holistic psychological approach, including both the patient and family, before more invasive pharmaceutical or surgical measures.” Osborne he told Fox News Digital.
Dr. Brett Osborn, a Florida neurologist and longevity expert, said he agrees with the position statement published by ACPeds. (Dr. Brett Osborne)
He said taking hormone-changing therapy and transitioning to the opposite sex were “all the rage” but the data suggested there were no long-term mental health benefits.
“Additionally, those who choose hormone-altering therapy are not only potentially suffering from the following disorders: sexual developmentOsborne warned that “testosterone and estrogen are the hormones primarily manipulated in such treatments and are essential for memory formation and mood.”
Study finds gender dysphoria is on the rise among young people amid ‘increasing acceptance’
The doctor also addressed the risks associated with “gender-affirming” surgery.
“Adolescents are choosing sex reassignment surgery almost on a whim before undergoing intensive psychotherapy,” he said. “However, this is short-sighted and the decision is often tainted by ongoing psychological issues.”
He added: “Such surgeries permanently change a person’s appearance and have irreversible consequences such as infertility and sexual dysfunction.”
“Adolescents are choosing sex reassignment surgery almost on a whim, before undergoing intensive psychotherapy,” the doctor said. (Cyberguy.com)
Adolescents don’t live long enough to make such high-level decisions, Osborne said.
“They’re confused,” he said. “We have to look for alternatives.”
Dr. Mark Siegel, Clinical Professor, School of Medicine New York University Langone Medical Center The Fox News medical contributor was also not involved in the ACPeds investigation, but he did comment on the findings of what he called a “conservative advocacy group.”
“Hormone change therapy can interfere not only with sexual development but also with brain development.”
“I support a more conservative approach to minors,” he told Fox News Digital.
“Long-term effects of puberty blockers can include bone loss, decreased concentration, learning disabilities, and impaired fertility.”
“In most cases, I think it makes sense to treat the underlying mental health concern before jumping to treatment,” Siegel added. including surgery, it may be difficult to undo it. ”
Dr. Mark Siegel, a clinical professor of medicine at New York University Langone Medical Center and a medical contributor for Fox News, warned about the long-term effects of puberty blockers. (Fox News)
The doctor also stressed that gender issues should not be overly politicized.
“This means not layering ideologies or forcing physicians to act a certain way or under pressure,” Siegel said.
A growing majority of Americans see sex as a biological reality, new poll finds
“The welfare of the child must come first, and in this case that means providing support very slowly to children and teens with gender dysphoria.”
Siegel also pointed out that the UK and many European countries, from Sweden to France, are restricting gender-affirming care for young people in favor of mental health support.
Organizations supporting gender affirmation procedures
The American Medical Association (AMA) states on its website that “Improving access to gender-affirming care is an important tool for improving gender outcomes.” health outcomes For transgender people. ”
“Receiving gender-affirming care is associated with dramatic reductions in attempted suicide rates and attempted suicide rates. depression and anxietysubstance use decreased, HIV medication adherence improved, and rates of harmful self-prescribed hormone use decreased,” the group claimed.
The UK and many European countries, from Sweden to France, are restricting gender-affirming care for young people in favor of mental health support. (St. Petersburg)
The AMA also said it supports public and private health insurance coverage for treatment of gender dysphoria.
The Office of Population Affairs (OASH), part of the Department of Health and Human Services, issued a similar statement in support of gender-affirming care, calling it “a medical practice that includes medical, surgical, mental health, spiritual health, etc.” “Supportive format”. Non-medical services for transgender and non-binary people. ”
“The welfare of the child must come first.”
“Research shows that gender-affirming care improves the mental health and overall well-being of gender-variant children and adolescents,” the statement continued.
OASH argued that gender-affirming care can allow “transgender and non-binary children and youth” to focus on their social transition and increase their confidence as they navigate the health care system.
Click here to sign up for our health newsletter
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) also expresses support for gender-affirming care, stating on its website that it provides “inclusive gender-affirming and developmentally appropriate access to health care for youth.” He says he recommends it.
The AAP also requires electronic medical records, notifications, and research files to be updated to reflect patients’ preferred gender identity.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Fox News Digital reached out to the AMA, OASH, and the American Academy of Pediatrics for comment on the ACPeds study.
For more health articles, visit: www.foxnews.com/health.
