Nearly 80 years after the Holocaust, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said the country’s responsibility for the Nazi genocide also applies to immigrants from Islamic countries. Those who refuse to uphold that responsibility, he said, should leave Germany.
Merz made the remarks Nov. 6 at a reception in Berlin for Germany’s Maccabiah Jewish sports delegation. A basketball coach had told him that athletes were afraid to wear their red Maccabi jackets, which display the Star of David, on German streets for fear of being attacked.
The German Press Agency, dpa, reported that Merz referred to a 1985 speech by former president Richard von Weizsäcker. Von Weizsäcker said young people were not responsible for Nazi crimes, but did bear responsibility for how those crimes were remembered and understood. Merz called that principle enduring, adding that it applied to immigrants in light of recent antisemitic offenses committed by Muslim immigrants.
Merz’s office released his prepared remarks but did not publish what he said during the question-and-answer session with the athletes. Asked about the comments, a government spokesperson said the Chancellor’s words spoke for themselves.
Political scientist Daniel Schatz, who holds a doctorate from Berlin’s Humboldt University, said Merz was right to make the statement and was meeting Germany’s historical obligation. He said the remarks reflected the German principle of “Staatsräson,” under which responsibility for the Holocaust and a commitment to Israel’s security are central to the country’s domestic and foreign policy.
Schatz said the fear Jewish athletes feel about wearing clothing bearing the Star of David points to a serious failure by the state. He added that Jewish people should be able to live openly and safely, and that a country whose identity is built partly on “Never Again” cannot accept a situation where people feel they must hide who they are to stay safe.
Simone Rodan-Benzaquen, a senior European envoy at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, said people who make Germany their home share a responsibility to protect Jewish life, regardless of whether they share the country’s historical guilt.
She described this as a core issue of integration. Learning the language and finding work matter, she said, but so does accepting a Jewish neighbor’s equal right to live openly and safely. She called for transparency around foreign funding, oversight of publicly supported organizations, enforcement against threats and violence, and backing for Muslims who challenge antisemitism in their communities.
Since the Oct. 7 attack, Germany has experienced what Janek Treiber, a research fellow at Dresden University of Technology, described as a cultural conflict. Some people express solidarity with Palestinians and view Israel as oppressive, while others strongly support Israel. Germany’s history, he said, gives the debate particular intensity.
Treiber said Merz’s comments had not prompted the same level of reaction as some of his earlier statements on migration. He suggested that most people would agree immigrants should respect Germany’s constitutional order and reckon with its historical legacy.
Rodan-Benzaquen said the real test would be whether the athletes could wear their team jackets on German streets without fear.
Germany’s delegation to the 2026 Maccabiah Games was Europe’s most successful team at the competition in Israel, a major international sporting event for Jewish athletes.


