Criticism of Harvard’s DEI Policies

Harvard alumnus Shabbos Kestenbaum recently voiced strong criticism against the university’s diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) policies, reflecting thoughts shared by a former professor who left after four decades at the institution.

“It’s shocking but not surprising,” Kestenbaum remarked, suggesting that Harvard’s focus on DEI often values ideology over merit.

His comments mirror those of former Harvard professor James Hankins, who explained his reasons for departing the university in an essay for Compact Magazine. Hankins had described his withdrawal in 2021 amid a surge of restrictions from the pandemic, although he had honored a severance agreement that recently lapsed.

Hankins criticized what he sees as Harvard’s neglect of merit-based standards, claiming that DEI priorities have altered recruitment and admissions processes while ignoring the importance of studying Western civilization.

Kestenbaum echoed these sentiments during an appearance on Fox & Friends, stating that countries that neglect their history might not have a promising future. “My biggest concern is the greater social impact, particularly the disillusionment of America’s youth,” he said.

He expressed that when cultural elites and academics downplay the value of one’s history and identity, it could lead young people to feel disconnected from their society. Kestenbaum stressed the importance of recognizing and valuing the principles of Western civilization, which he believes should not be overshadowed by outside ideologies. He called attention to what he perceives as long-standing issues of anti-white, anti-Asian racism, and anti-American sentiments within higher education.

Harvard University has not yet responded to requests for commentary regarding these criticisms.