New York High School Football Forfeit Raises Questions About Eligibility
Thanksgiving is a week away, which means it may be time to move that turkey from the freezer to the fridge. A standard bird can take several days to thaw, and I’ve learned the hard way that trying to speed things up in a bucket of water on Thanksgiving morning is not much fun.
On to football. A playoff game in New York has turned into a messy debate about rules, responsibility and whether a coach should have stepped down.
Middletown High School beat Valley Central 48-15 earlier this month, improving to 10-0 and advancing in the playoffs. But Middletown had used a special-teams player for eight plays, totaling 53 seconds, even though he was ineligible for postseason play after joining the team midway through the season.
Coaches from Middletown’s next opponent spotted the violation while reviewing game footage and reported it to the league. After appeals and even court hearings, Middletown was forced to forfeit the game.
Head coach Tim Strenfel, who had led the team for 10 years, resigned this week. Whether the penalty was fair, and whether the resignation is connected to anything beyond the eligibility issue, remains open to debate. There may be more to the story, but based on what’s known so far, it’s hard to say why he chose to leave.
Major League Baseball commissioner Rob Manfred also drew attention with comments about a possible lockout. He said the decision would be made “at the last possible moment,” then added that he wasn’t especially fond of Thanksgiving and that MLB would be available to negotiate whenever needed.
That’s an unusual holiday to dismiss. Thanksgiving seems to be broadly popular, though perhaps I’m giving it too much credit. Still, with another labor dispute looming, baseball fans may have reason to worry about next season.
Meanwhile, the tension between Troy Aikman and Joe Buck remains a topic of conversation. Their partnership in the broadcast booth has long looked polished, but recent comments have fueled speculation about how well the two get along. There’s plenty of football left this season, so it will be interesting to see whether anything else surfaces.
And then there’s the new John Madden biopic starring Nicolas Cage. Clips from the movie have been circulating online, and the reaction has been rough. It looks strange enough that, honestly, I might have to watch it myself.
Thursday night’s Colts-Texans game may not be everyone’s idea of a must-watch, so the Madden movie could be an alternative. Or maybe not. I’ll see how the evening goes.






