I voted to allow trade with China. Twenty-five years later, it’s time for us to correct that mistake.

I voted to allow trade with China. Twenty-five years later, it’s time for us to correct that mistake.

In December 2001, China joined the World Trade Organization and became more deeply integrated into the global economy. That step followed a U.S. decision the year before to grant China permanent normal trade relations, giving it access to American markets on terms usually extended to close partners such as Britain and Israel. I was one of 83 senators who voted for that measure.

Looking back, I consider it the worst vote I cast during my 14 years in the Senate.

Since then, China has become an economic and military power. Its government has committed atrocities against Uyghurs, Tibetans and Falun Gong practitioners, built ties with authoritarian governments, and supported human rights abuses in other countries. It is also expanding its nuclear arsenal while building a navy larger than America’s by ship count.

Opening the WTO door to China was a profound policy mistake. We thought that participating in the global economy might make the country more open and free—that greater contact with democratic nations would, in time, draw China toward freedom. Perhaps we wanted to believe it.

That expectation has ended in a tragic miscalculation. It is time to end China’s permanent normal trade relations with the United States.

We are in a new Cold War. The United States never gave the Soviet Union favored access to our markets; we understood that we were in a contest between communist dictatorship and capitalist democracy.

China’s leaders took a different approach. They presented themselves as partners while building their strength, and now argue that Washington is trying to hold back China’s growth and deny it a proper place in a multipolar world. But that argument disguises a larger ambition: global dominance. China has been working against us for decades, and we are only beginning to grasp the scale of it.

Restricting Soviet access to American markets limited the money available to support its military. When the Soviets struggled to keep pace with President Ronald Reagan’s defense buildup, their economy could not sustain the competition, and the country eventually collapsed.

We helped weaken that system then. It may be time to apply similar pressure again.

One starting point would be to tell the Chinese Communist Party that it must allow religious freedom—or face a gradual separation of Western economies from China’s.

Think of it as a Helsinki Accord 2.0: the West would make continued access to its markets contingent on progress in human rights. The prospect could encourage debate and reform within China. Losing access to American markets would carry a serious economic cost, so the government would have a strong reason to begin respecting the basic rights of its people.

About 100 million Christians in China could practice their faith without government restrictions and constant surveillance. Falun Gong practitioners, Tibetans and Uyghurs could also have reason to hope for change. Those forced to flee their homes might one day see a different future for the places they left behind.

In a way, this would pursue the very result we expected from trade with China in the first place: greater freedom for its people.

If China refuses, that decision would strengthen the case for the United States and its allies to loosen their economic ties with the country. It would also help explain to Americans why trade cannot simply continue as usual with a repressive communist government. If people in China are denied the freedom to choose even how they practice their faith, we should not help finance a government that denies them that basic right.

Democracies have an important advantage: they can recognize mistakes and change course. The free world made a serious error 25 years ago. Now it should correct it.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News