“The writing is Elvish, from an ancient tradition, but the language is Mordor’s, and I won’t repeat it. In the Common Tongue, it says something like this: One Ring to rule them all, one Ring to find them, one Ring to bring them together—and in the darkness, blame a lifetime of oppression by patriarchy and white supremacy for keeping a marginalized people from reaching their potential in an unjust system.”
—J.R.R. Tolkien, if he had written for Amazon
I stopped watching Amazon’s “The Rings of Power.” I had to.
Imagine your grandfather received the Medal of Honor. Then imagine someone who knew him during the war repeatedly telling you made-up stories about his service. Eventually, you might tell that person to go to hell, too.
Not because you’re scared of the truth, as some on the left might say. Because you know and care about the truth, and false stories dishonor what is real and verifiable.
We live in a world where truth matters. We feel a duty to defend it, even when it appears in fiction.
God is with us
“The Lord of the Rings” is more than a fantasy story. Tolkien saw it as fundamentally religious and Catholic, shaped by Christian ideas about creation, temptation, sacrifice, providence, and redemption. Across all those pages of hobbits, kings, wizards, and rings runs one central truth: Emmanuel, God with us.
Tolkien began building his mythology in the years around World War I, when new technologies brought enormous destruction to people and the natural world. He served in France, where Christian British soldiers and their allies were killed by Christian Germans. Artillery shattered men and left the landscape scarred. The world seemed senseless and cruel, and after more than 1,900 years, it could feel as if Emmanuel had vanished.
But Tolkien did not give up hope. He held on to his faith in God and in humanity. Good could still prevail through courage, mercy, sacrifice, and providence. The greatest act of goodness—God coming to live among us—had already taken place.
That is why the Ring’s destruction falls on March 25, the Feast of the Annunciation, when Mary accepted the angel’s message and conceived Jesus. The date was also traditionally linked to Christ’s Crucifixion. “The Word became flesh and dwelt among us”—or, more literally, pitched his tent among us.
That day changed the course of things. Evil would no longer act without opposition. The orcs who burned, looted, and killed would face good men strengthened by God’s presence. Emmanuel.
Backstory bathos
This is the world Tolkien made, and this understanding of good and evil is what gives it meaning. Amazon inherited that world and its mythology. What did it do with them?
Powerful women. Diversity. Misunderstandings. Moral confusion. And, naturally, backstory.
The left does love a sympathetic backstory. “Lindsay Clancy is the real victim—do you know how sad she was?” In this telling, a painful past becomes an argument against judging someone who strangled her children. Backstory turns into justification.
Lucifer has one of the richest backstories in Christian thought, explored over centuries by writers from Saint Augustine to John Milton in “Paradise Lost.” He was an angel, a bearer of light, who chose evil. Some say he rebelled against God’s plan to redeem humanity. A God willing to come down and live among flawed human beings was not someone he wanted to serve.
See? Once you know Lucifer’s perspective, perhaps he doesn’t seem so bad.
It’s a little like “Wicked,” where the green witch turns out to be good and the pretty pink one is more complicated than she first appears. The ugly or frightening figure is misunderstood, and maybe deserves our sympathy after all.
Backstory that lets someone off the hook.
I might try that approach at confession next time.
“Bless me, Father, for I have sinned. Yes, I cursed and drank, and when I hit my thumb with a hammer while fixing a barbed-wire fence, I yelled something awful. But Satan is misunderstood, you know. If we considered his pain and tried to see things from his point of view, perhaps you’d realize the Church is at fault for judging me. I’m only trying to encourage a shared understanding.”
If I actually said that, I hope Father would hit me in the face with the hammer.
Orc mindset
A backstory can explain evil, but it cannot excuse it. Tolkien treated evil as evil. Amazon took that clear idea and gave the orcs a sympathetic home life. The orcs. I’ll say it again: the show gives them a wife and baby, apparently to make us feel for them.
Tolkien’s orcs did have personalities. They had names, complaints, and ambitions. In “The Two Towers,” two orc captains, Shagrat and Gorbag, grumble about their leaders and dream of abandoning the war to make their own way. Their picture of freedom is simple: a few loyal companions, lots of loot, and nobody giving orders. They don’t want to stop pillaging and killing. They want to do it without anyone supervising them.
Tolkien also wrestled with a difficult theological question: could creatures corrupted by evil still be redeemed? He never settled it completely. But in his stories, whatever grievances the orcs may have, they remain willing agents of cruelty and destruction.
That distinction matters. A history may help explain wickedness. It doesn’t make wickedness acceptable.
Amazon seems to have missed the difference. In season two, we meet Glûg, an orc who is worried about another war. He has a partner and a baby. The writers have made him a family man with ordinary domestic concerns, perhaps hoping viewers will sympathize with his situation.
The orcs have become victims of circumstance.
The orcs.
In the prayer to Saint Michael the Archangel, we ask him to cast Satan and evil spirits out of the world because they seek the ruin of souls. We ask him to defeat the orcs, not to sit down and hear them out, learn their histories, give them a platform in Geneva, or build a community center on the theory that an orc sports league might change their behavior.
No. We ask Saint Michael to defeat them because they serve the opposite of Emmanuel. They serve Satan, and they are not trying to pitch a tent and live peacefully among us.
Tolkien was not writing empty make-believe. He was writing about truth. Amazon, in my view, has turned that work into a hollow set of layers, each containing only more of itself, until nothing is left.
Fount of wisdom
Consider C.S. Lewis’ “The Screwtape Letters,” dedicated to Tolkien. An experienced devil advises his nephew, a junior tempter assigned to corrupt a young Englishman. Much of the humor comes from imagining hell as a vast bureaucracy, full of office politics, rivalry, and ambitious functionaries nursing small grudges.
Now imagine Amazon adapting it. The production spends hundreds of millions on a fluorescent-lit underworld of cubicles, where devils argue over promotions and complain about management. Screwtape’s manipulation and Wormwood’s incompetence are all there. We learn about the institutional pressures that supposedly drive these poor devils. Maybe Screwtape’s cruelty comes from childhood trauma. Maybe hell is the real villain, trapping its staff in an abusive system.
It could look impressive. It might even be funny. But Lewis’ joke is that the devils are so warped by pride and self-interest that they can’t understand goodness. Their petty bureaucracy reflects their corruption; it doesn’t excuse it. Make them sympathetic victims of an unjust institution, and you miss both Lewis’ Christianity and much of the book’s humor.
As Saint Paul writes in 1 Corinthians, “If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal.”
Without knowing God, a pagan can’t sing songs of godly truth; he can only make noise. He can’t tell the story of Emmanuel. He can put words on a page, but that is not the same thing.
Tolkien was doing more than writing books. He was conveying religious truth because, in his understanding, God was with him. He sat by the fire with God, shared stories and songs, and came to know and love Him as a friend and brother. God was an endless source of inspiration for Tolkien.
Tolkien drew deeply from that source. Amazon’s pagan writers, I think, use it to wash their feet.
Sometimes people are called to fight, as Tolkien was during the Great War. Sometimes the task is to protect what is good, beautiful, and true from forces that would destroy it. Some were called to reclaim Jerusalem; others to defend Vienna and Malta.
This fight is simpler, at least for now: don’t watch.
Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” is not merely bad television. It betrays what Tolkien gave us: a story animated by the truth of Emmanuel. The best response is to switch it off.
Then spend time with Emmanuel—in church, in Scripture, in books and art and music, around campfires, and in friendship. Let’s grow stronger in Christ together.
There are orcs to kill.






