Rep. Mike Lawler Critiques NYC Mayoral Proposal
Rep. Mike Lawler (R-NY) is challenging Zohran Mamdani, the winner of the New York City mayoral primary. He has introduced the Mom-Tick Act, which aims to investigate the implications of government-owned grocery stores, looking at their potential to support local businesses, farmers, and supply chains.
The act, also known as the Measurement of Unfavorable Market Turmoil and National Impact (Mamdani) Act, seeks to partner with the Department of Agriculture. Lawler intends to involve the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to conduct a thorough study on how taxpayer-funded grocery stores might distort food prices, impact local grocery stores, disrupt supply chains, and undermine competition in the grocery retail sector.
“Government-run grocery stores raise serious questions about market fairness and responsibility to taxpayers,” Lawler stated. He emphasized that the Mamdani Act is crucial for assessing the potential effects of such proposals before committing public funds, as there are risks of weakening local businesses, disrupting supply chains, and ultimately harming consumers.
Lawler has criticized Mamdani’s grocery initiative, calling it “straight from the Marxist playbook.” He cited examples from Kansas City, highlighting the problems experienced with taxpayer-funded grocery stores, such as empty shelves and high levels of theft, saying, “this is a good reason to support the Mamdani Act and scrutinize government-run grocery operations!”
Additionally, the ongoing debate over Mamdani’s grocery plan has sparked criticism about misinterpretations of the city’s funding data. Mamdani claimed the initiative would cost $60 million, to be funded by cutting a $140 million subsidy meant for private grocery stores, stating that funding should stem from private investment rather than city revenue.
Lawler urges that the FTC should monitor public grocery stores to examine if they benefit from subsidies or regulatory advantages that might alter the market. This upcoming study will look into the impacts on food prices, the interests of producers, charitable food systems, and the long-term sustainability of the market. The FTC is expected to report its findings to Congress, along with annual suggestions for legislative or administrative improvements.
The Mamdani Act emerges amidst increasing skepticism about such initiatives. Concerns have been raised regarding potential mishandling and inefficiencies in government-run grocery stores. One grocery store in Manhattan noted that the plan could lead to issues of “corruption and money laundering,” while others pointed out that broader problems like crime and poverty need addressing instead.
“New Yorkers deserve practical solutions, not a socialist dream that has repeatedly failed when implemented,” Lawler concluded.

