Lindsay Clancy has won a limited legal reprieve in the case accusing her of killing her three young children in 2023. On Thursday, a justice referred her appeal to the full Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, legal observers said.
Clancy’s lawyers appealed Judge William Sullivan’s decision to reject their request to dismiss the charges on double-jeopardy grounds. Justice Elizabeth Dewar sent the matter to the full court, which set deadlines for written arguments next month and scheduled oral arguments for January. Jury selection for Clancy’s retrial is set to begin March 29.
“This is a small win for the defense,” said Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge who has followed the case. He said the appeal could have implications for future trials, though he described the legal question as difficult.
“From a common-sense perspective, the defendant’s position would interfere with jury deliberations in future cases and presents an unworkable framework for handling complaints from deliberating jurors,” Lu said.
Clancy’s first trial ended in a hung jury on Sept. 4, after a week of deliberations. Her defense argues that the lone juror who favored a guilty verdict should have been removed and replaced with an alternate after the foreperson accused him of disregarding the law on reasonable doubt.
In an earlier ruling, Sullivan said he was skeptical of the foreperson’s claim. The holdout juror, Michael Desronvil, has said in interviews after the trial that he believed the evidence showed Clancy murdered her children: Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months.
Clancy, now 36, argued at trial that postpartum psychosis left her unable to understand or control her actions and that she should not be found guilty because of a mental disease or defect.
Prosecutors alleged that Clancy planned the killings, sent her husband out to run errands, and killed the children before he returned. They said she then jumped from a second-story window in a suicide attempt that left her paralyzed.
At trial, Clancy did not dispute that she strangled the children with exercise bands on Jan. 24, 2023. Her husband, Patrick Clancy, returned home to find her seriously injured in the yard and the children in the basement.
Desronvil said the prosecution’s evidence persuaded him that Clancy had methodically planned what he described as the “execution” of her children. He pointed in particular to the courtroom recording of Patrick Clancy’s 911 call.
“That was really big for me, you know, from watching the video and also listening in the courtroom,” Desronvil said. “The thought process that goes behind … to fulfill the commitment of doing that.”
The appeal centers on whether there was “manifest necessity” to declare a mistrial after jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict. Clancy’s lawyer, Kevin Reddington, had asked for the holdout to be removed and replaced with an alternate after the foreperson sent a note accusing him of ignoring reasonable doubt about the prosecution’s case.
In a 17-page order issued earlier this month, Sullivan concluded that a mistrial was necessary and said he was skeptical of the foreperson’s accusation against Desronvil.
Carol Erskine, a retired judge and child-welfare advocate, said it can be difficult to get this kind of appeal before the full Supreme Judicial Court. She said she filed three during her career as a lawyer, and only one was accepted.
“The issue has to be one of exceptional circumstances, constitutional rights at stake, urgent, and the case cannot wait for the ordinary appellate process,” Erskine said.


