Masapekua Park is known for its walkable distance to local parks.
This Long Island community has recently been recognized as one of the best places to live by a major ranking organization. Locals seem to embrace this sentiment, casually asking, “Why not us?”
The neighborhood has had its share of challenges, notably an unwanted association with a suspected serial killer in nearby Gilgo Beach. Despite this, the local school’s “Chief” branding has been defended passionately amidst ongoing debates about Native American imagery.
“This is where you want to start a family,” said Michael Cassano, a lifelong resident and owner of the American Beauty Restaurant in Masapekua Park Village.
With a population of about 17,000, he proudly notes that the unique character of the town sets it apart.
“I take pride in that—we’re all rallying around the Chiefs logo,” he explained. “The community comes together to support various initiatives.”
Masapekua not only tops New York’s list, but it also ranks among America’s top 150 places, especially praised for its quality of life.
Current and new residents generally feel that this town represents a perfect blend of American values, with many surprised by its proximity to New York City.
Cassano’s wife, Maria, noted that the median home price is around $746,500, enriching the community experience. “We all know each other’s names,” she added.
She highlighted how the town rallied around the family of murdered NYPD officer Jonathan Diller, showcasing a norm of community support, particularly evident during the busy spring of 2024.
Killer’s Reputation
Contrasting the image of the Gilgo Beach murderer, Rex Heuermann, Cassano presents a positive perspective of their town. Though the unsettling news shook residents initially, life has returned to a semblance of normalcy now that media attention has waned.
Vinny and Allie Frazzetto moved close to the infamous Heuermann House last summer, undeterred by the area’s past.
“The long-standing reputation and strong community values of Masapekua Park overshadow everything else,” Allie said.
In fact, Masapekua Park also received high marks for public safety, claiming a spot as one of the safest communities according to major reports.
Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman commended Mayor Daniel Pearl for his exceptional work on housing issues.
New Beginnings
Allie, who is due to have her first baby in September, reflected on her choice to leave Bayside, Queens, for the family-friendly setting of Masapekua Park.
“I love the blend of a big school district with the intimacy of a small neighborhood,” she mentioned, having roots in Garden City, which is known as Jerry Seinfeld’s hometown.
Vinny, originally from Bucks County, Pennsylvania, expressed excitement about meeting neighbors while looking to recreate a supportive community he remembered from his childhood.
“We wanted a great school district, a backyard, and a fresh start,” he shared.
Masapekua High School’s athletic teams also shone in the spring, winning county titles in baseball, softball, and lacrosse.
“We boast success not by coincidence, but through community and family support,” Oyster Bay Supervisor Joe Saladino remarked, a Massapequa alumnus.
The vibe in the park is diverse, as Rishi Mataden, a long-time manager at a local pub, observes the varied day-to-day lives of residents.
“You can find someone in construction sitting next to a Wall Street worker, and everyone feels at ease,” he noted, reflecting on the sense of community.
Mataden, initially surprised by the town’s accolades, now sees the beauty in their shared lifestyle.
“You start to appreciate things more,” he said, concluding, “And you realize, why not us?”
