Long Island Residents Oppose New Boarding School

Residents in Long Island are voicing their objections to a planned Muslim boys’ boarding school that aims to accommodate 120 teenagers, arguing it would disrupt the peace in their suburban area.

A faction of homeowners in Bayshore claims the proposed dormitory violates local ordinances, specifically the Saxon Avenue zoning regulations, for a 13-acre waterfront plot that was previously home to a Catholic seminary.

Kevin Colgan, an Islip resident and a prominent figure in the protest group “Saxon Says No,” remarked, “The intended use by the new owners is far too intensive for such a tranquil residential setting.” He emphasized that their concerns are focused on protecting zoning laws rather than targeting any specific individual or organization. “Zoning regulations are there to maintain the neighborhood’s character and quality of life, ensuring land use is suitable for the area,” he added.

Opponents are urging the Islip Town Board of Zoning Appeals to stop the development of the property, which was sold for $5 million earlier this year.

The American Muslim Association, partly based at the Suleymaniye Mosque in Dix Hills, acquired the property from the Roman Catholic Missionaries of Montfort. During the recent Zoning Commission meeting, various commissioners expressed the opinion that the dormitory proposal aligns with local law. The meeting drew hundreds of concerned residents, lasting over five hours.

Anna Chan, who lives directly across from the proposed school site, shared her thoughts, stating, “When we bought our home a decade ago, we relied on zoning protections in making such a significant investment in a community of single-family homes. This zoning was put in place to maintain the neighborhood’s character.”

Many residents voiced concerns that the school’s establishment would negatively impact the neighborhood’s atmosphere. They argued that boarding schools should not be located in residential areas due to potential increases in noise and traffic congestion. Questions also arose about a potential child care center associated with the school.

“A school for 120 teenage boys, with all the noise from their recreational activities, would you want that near your home?” questioned Isla Belkitis, a nearby resident.

On the other side, supporters of the school, including attorney Samuel L. Bifulco, advocate that the proposal is fully compliant with city regulations and that stringent oversight for students would minimize disruptive activities. They aim to establish a school that offers comprehensive spiritual and educational training, including full-time Islamic-centered curriculum and community programs.