The NFL Is Business and Tough Decisions Loom

It’s no secret: the NFL operates like a business.

For coaches, success means securing wins or facing the inevitable consequences of failure.

Last week, Brian Daboll’s tenure with the New York Giants came to an end, raising concerns about the futures of other coaches across the league.

With that in mind, let’s take a look at how various coaches are faring and whether they’re feeling the heat—or if their time is truly running out.

A recurring issue for many of these coaches seems to point to the quarterback position.

The situation with Kyler Murray in Arizona appears to be reaching its conclusion. While the Cardinals are tied to Murray through next season, whispers suggest the team might be contemplating a shift sooner rather than later. Speculation is brewing that he could end up with a different team—or even different sport—next season.

If Murray’s exit becomes a reality, it might allow Jonathan Gannon to keep his job, but there are other serious issues at play here.

Gannon took over in Arizona aiming to rebuild after his stint as the Eagles’ defensive coordinator. Unfortunately, since his arrival, the Cardinals’ defense has lagged near the bottom ranks of the league. Currently, they’re sitting at 20th in total defense and 25th in points allowed. In fact, Gannon’s first season saw the team ranked 31st defensively. Murray’s struggles provide some context, yet any further defensive lapses could jeopardize Gannon’s position.

After parting ways with Chris Grier, Miami Dolphins rumors indicated confidence in Mike McDaniel, suggesting he might get some leeway to hold onto his job.

Following those rumors, Miami notched two victories, including a surprising upset at home against the Buffalo Bills. With upcoming matches against New Orleans, the Jets, and the Bengals, the Dolphins might find more winnable games ahead.

But the question lingers: will six wins suffice to save McDaniel’s job? Possibly not. Still, it feels like his journey in Miami remains open-ended.

There’s been talk that the Bills’ owners might hesitate to make drastic changes ahead of a new stadium opening, yet that shouldn’t excuse mediocrity. The Bills are 7-3 and play well, but one wonders, what’s the tipping point?

If Buffalo finishes the season strongly yet falters early in the playoffs, when will the pressure increase on Sean McDermott? Should a team like the Browns dismiss someone like Kevin Stefanski, could that push Buffalo towards seeking a new direction?

Many uncertainties exist, but there’s little room left for the Bills’ management to tolerate continued playoff letdowns.

As for Raheem Morris, his salvation might hinge on Michael Penix Jr. being sidelined for the season. It’s tough to expect great success with Kirk Cousins at the helm.

While Atlanta shows promise for improvement next year, the Falcons were anticipated to contend for the playoffs last season. Instead, they seem to be aimed at securing a low draft pick while giving the Rams a first-round choice.

After a recent game against the Panthers where Bryce Young set new franchise records, it’s clear that Carolina is on the rise while Atlanta struggles to keep pace.

Morris has solid coaching credentials, but it’s uncertain if he’s a builder of teams—a critical question as the end of the season approaches.

And then there’s Zac Taylor. Honestly, it’s hard to find a less effective head coach in the NFL right now. The Bengals have often succeeded despite his leadership, not because of it. Blaming the team’s challenges solely on Joe Burrow’s injury feels like an excuse for someone whose performance has been below par.

Cincinnati would likely be better off with a more dependable coach in charge. It’s just that straightforward. Yet, given the current financial constraints of their owner, there’s only so much time left for them to continue this way.

Kevin Stefanski gets viewed as a capable coach plagued by a poor roster, but he can’t remain untouchable if the Browns keep landing among the league’s worst. His record isn’t favorable at all, and although he holds two AP Coach of the Year titles, it’s hard to ignore how little he accomplished in the playoffs despite a season with 11 wins.

As they head towards what looks like a full overhaul, Myles Garrett stands out as a key player worth retaining while they prepare for the 2025 draft with two first-round picks. This could be their best chance to find transformative talent.

Timing is critical in football. Stefanski seems better suited to elevate an established roster rather than revive a struggling one. That could seal his fate with the Browns.

Already departed: Brian Daboll (Giants), Brian Callahan (Titans)