Nicolas Cage’s Madden biopic lets down both the coach and the film, while Christian Bale’s Al Davis steals the spotlight

Nicolas Cage’s Madden biopic lets down both the coach and the film, while Christian Bale’s Al Davis steals the spotlight

Amazon Prime’s streaming page opened Thursday with Nicolas Cage’s face transformed by heavy prosthetics, false eyebrows and a rather unconvincing hairpiece. The image promised a biopic about John Madden, a personality as outsized as the coach himself.

That was the idea, anyway. “Madden” was meant to tell the story of a coach who became a broadcaster and then a video-game icon, shaping the experience of generations of NFL fans.

By the end of the 110-minute film, though, I found myself wishing it had focused on Al Davis. Christian Bale’s performance as the late Raiders owner is terrific, while Cage never quite convinces as Madden.

Here’s a casting opinion that may not go over well: whoever chose Cage apparently hadn’t seen Frank Caliendo’s Madden impression. Caliendo could have been an inspired pick. Height might have been an issue, sure, but elevator shoes would have been easier to accept than Cage seeming to play a lightly disguised version of himself, with little effort to capture the voice or mannerisms football fans watched for decades.

Cage became a major star with films like “The Rock” and “Family Man.” But his familiar screen persona overwhelms this role. I just couldn’t see Madden.

It was easier to buy former Seahawks running back Marshawn Lynch as an EA Sports computer whiz than to accept Cage as the coach. Sienna Miller’s appearance as Carol Davis, some convincing football footage, a nostalgic soundtrack and Bale’s strong work couldn’t pull the movie together.

The football scenes were oddly entertaining, at least. They felt a bit like NFL Films made under the influence of 1970s psychedelics.

Bale, on the other hand, completely won me over as Davis. He captures the Raiders owner’s defiant streak and the particular mix of genius and rebellion. In some scenes, I genuinely felt I was watching Davis. Bale gets the Brooklyn accent, with just a trace of Southern inflection, remarkably well.

I met Davis once, in the early 1990s, at an NFL spring meeting in Orlando. I was at a urinal when he came to the one beside me, dressed head to toe in white Raiders gear, with dark sunglasses in silver frames. He glanced over and asked my name, then where I worked. He said he couldn’t wait to get “these damn meetings over with.”

After we washed our hands, he shook mine and told me, “Good luck, kid. Just win, baby.” Davis really was a caricature of himself, and somehow that was part of his charm.

There’s a funny scene during a late-1970s offseason meeting when Davis introduces his young son Mark to Madden. The boy has a red bowl cut that looks like an earlier version of the hairstyle Mark Davis still wears as the Raiders’ owner.

When the film ends, it’s hard to decide whether you’ve watched a documentary, a drama or a comedy. It doesn’t quite work as any of them. A friend of a friend saw it on opening day and summed it up this way: “Just watched Madden. It is preposterously awful … and yet I sort of loved it.”

The first part, at least, sounds about right.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News