Stephen A. Smith is daring his white bosses to stop his anti-white remarks

Stephen A Smith displays his privilege by ridiculing the Lakers' lineup for having too many 'White guys'

Stephen A. Smith appears to be testing how far he can go with his repeated comments about White basketball players. He seems confident his bosses at ESPN won’t step in.

In July, Smith questioned whether the Los Angeles Lakers could win a title with Luka Doncic, Austin Reaves and Walker Kessler as their leading players. His argument was that no team led by three White players had won an NBA championship.

At first, it sounded like an offhand observation. But Smith kept returning to it. Last week, he said not only that such a team had never won, but that it never would. This week, he urged Black NBA players to make sure it stayed that way.

Sophie Cunningham laughs at Stephen A. Smith’s claim about White NBA players

On his radio show, Smith challenged players including LeBron James, Kevin Durant, Stephen Curry, Anthony Edwards, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander and Victor Wembanyama to respond to a Lakers team led by three White players. He framed the question as whether they would let the NBA “hand” the sport to that group or remind them who they were.

Speaking with ESPN colleague Jay Williams, Smith defended his position by saying he wanted to ensure this generation of Black players did not give way to the White Lakers.

That’s a notable shift: first citing the past, then calling on players to preserve the pattern.

I’ve previously written about Kendrick Perkins, Gilbert Arenas and some WNBA commentators speaking as if basketball belongs to Black people. Smith’s comments rest on a similar assumption. When he asks Black players whether they’ll “hand the NBA” to White players, he suggests that the success of stars such as Doncic, Nikola Jokic, Caitlin Clark and Cooper Flagg threatens the sport’s supposed racial order.

The remarks are racially charged. Still, Smith seems to expect little pushback, in a culture where some people are more willing to excuse racism when a Black person is targeting White people. That needn’t be the standard.

Stephen A. Smith questions whether White players can win NBA titles

ESPN can decide that this kind of commentary crosses a line. Smith works for the network, which reportedly pays him more than $20 million a year. That salary doesn’t free the executives who hired him from managing what he says on air.

It’s worth asking how ESPN would react if a White host urged White golfers or hockey players to keep Black athletes from reaching the same level. Imagine Scott Van Pelt saying an NFL team shouldn’t build around a Black quarterback and a Black general manager because that pairing had never won a Super Bowl. Or picture him urging Josh Allen and Joe Burrow to stop the Chicago Bears from becoming the first team to do so this season.

Van Pelt would likely face immediate consequences, perhaps even racial sensitivity training before returning to television.

I’m not calling for ESPN to fire Smith. I’m challenging the network’s leaders to address his comments directly. There are reasons to do so beyond the apparent double standard.

For one thing, the basketball argument doesn’t add up. The Lakers’ trio is statistically among the NBA’s best this season. Their title chances, currently ranked 11th, are more often questioned because of concerns about the supporting cast. Those players are Black. Even within Smith’s racial framing, he seems to be directing his criticism at the wrong people.

Bobby Burack: Dianna Russini seeks sympathy without accountability in Mike Vrabel scandal

ESPN should also consider its audience. Most fans aren’t tuning in to sports television—especially during football season—to hear a host repeatedly suggest that White basketball players are inferior. It’s poor television, and frankly, thin analysis.

So why does Smith keep making the point? Perhaps he sees it as a way to deflect criticism. Taking aim at White players may help him regain favor with what he calls the “Black Community” when he comes under fire.

The timing is hard to ignore: this latest fixation followed criticism from that community over his interview with President Trump.

Smith is pursuing his own agenda, and ESPN is letting him. His comments now reflect on executives Jimmy Pitaro and Burke Magnus as much as they do on Smith. They gave him a prominent platform and, so far, have allowed a culture in which anti-White racism apparently doesn’t violate the company’s standards. They may simply be reluctant to tell him to stop.

Call it corporate cowardice. Smith, at least, has benefited from the arrangement.

His reported $100 million contract makes the contrast especially striking: a commentator paid that much should be held to a high standard, yet his analysis here leans on skin color.

Smith didn’t earn the position his bosses gave him, and ESPN is now dealing with the consequences of his repeated comments about White basketball players.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News