ESPN host Stephen A. Smith responded Tuesday to criticism that he failed to fact-check President Donald Trump during a White House interview last week. Smith said some people with experience in journalism had questioned why he did not challenge Trump more often.
His answer was that interrupting the president to correct each claim could have ended the conversation before it got going. “You don’t walk into the White House and talk to the President of the United States and plan on fact-checking him on the spot or interrupting him every sentence,” Smith said. “You know why? Because you won’t get through the interview.”
Smith said Trump can speak at length, stray from a question and embellish his remarks. Trying to address every questionable statement in real time, he argued, would take too long and could prompt Trump to leave. Smith wanted to challenge him on some points while also keeping him in the chair, noting that the president has walked out of interviews before.
He said he is willing to push back on interviewees, including Trump, but believes it matters when and how. In most cases, Smith said, his priority is to get a subject’s views clearly on the record, then check the claims afterward. That makes it possible to point out later when something was inaccurate.
Smith used the remainder of his video to examine several of Trump’s statements. He also urged people across the political spectrum to stop arguing in bad faith, saying that real-time fact-checking of every politician would make interviews difficult to secure. Democrats and Republicans alike, he said, can be reluctant to appear if they expect to be challenged constantly.
Smith has criticized politicians from both parties, but has also defended his decision to interview Trump despite disagreeing with his politics. Last month, he said on “The View” that Trump is the president and will remain in office until at least 2028, so avoiding him is not a realistic option.
Curtis Houck, managing editor of Newsbusters, said interviewing prominent figures involves a balance. Constantly interrupting with fact-checks or confrontational remarks, he said, can derail a conversation and leave its combative tone as the main takeaway. Houck added that Trump can make news when given room to speak, and said Smith had a valid point.
Representatives for Smith and the White House were contacted for comment.






