California Gubernatorial Debate Recap
As mail-in ballots approach for California voters, eight prominent candidates faced off at Pomona College in a pivotal primary debate on April 28, 2026. This debate provided a chance for candidates to showcase their unique qualities in a crowded field.
Analysts noted that the Democratic lineup featured some “political heavyweights,” including former Health and Human Services Secretary Xavier Becerra, San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan, former Congressman Katie Porter, billionaire Tom Steyer, State Superintendent Tony Thurmond, and former Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa. The Republican representatives included former Fox News commentator Steve Hilton and Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco.
The most heated exchange of the night focused on Becerra’s federal record. Mahan and Hilton frequently criticized Becerra’s management of public health during his time in office. Mahan specifically called out Becerra’s performance as health secretary during crises like the coronavirus pandemic and the monkeypox outbreak, arguing that it was inadequate.
This line of questioning highlighted a crucial debate theme: Will Becerra’s national experience benefit him, or could it be a liability in the gubernatorial race?
Hilton confronted Becerra after he proposed freezing insurance policies to safeguard homeowners, questioning the legality of such actions. “Have you read the statute that provides the governor’s emergency powers?” he asked, to which Becerra replied affirmatively. Hilton then argued, “Then you’ll see that what you’re proposing isn’t in there. You can’t do that.” Becerra countered, insisting that Hilton was mistaken.
As the candidates volleyed back and forth with attacks and answers, Bianco managed to stand out. He passionately declared, “If you want socialism, go elsewhere!” while criticizing Democrats for supporting taxpayer-funded health care. Bianco also drew attention to California’s struggling insurance market, claiming that government interventions had already failed in sectors like fire insurance. His campaign is centered on rejecting “broken Democratic Party policy.”
Speaking to a largely student audience, Bianco voiced concerns about the state’s future, saying, “I’m not afraid of anything. I really am not. But I’m worried that one of these people on this platform will be the next governor,” emphasizing that current policies could drive young people out of California.
His dissatisfaction with the debate format and opponents’ positions was palpable as he concluded with a blunt dismissal of the efforts: “an hour and a half that you’ll never get back.”
Local analysts described the discussions as “chaotic” and filled with interruptions, with various policy disagreements evident throughout the event.
Key Highlights from the Debate
One notable exchange revolved around California’s insurance crisis. Porter labeled the state’s FAIR plan as a “huge financial liability” and suggested a state-backed initiative to support insurance companies. This drew an immediate interruption from Bianco, who dismissed the idea as “single-payer” and a fail of environmental policy, leading to a tense rebuttal from Porter that circulated widely on social media.
Mahan took aim at Steyer’s qualifications, remarking, “The only homes Tom Steyer has built are private prisons and ICE detention centers,” referencing Steyer’s investment history. Steyer responded by positioning himself as a “billionaire who wants to tax other billionaires,” emphasizing his commitment to financing low-income housing.
Gasoline taxes were also a hot topic. Mahan called for an end to the state’s gas tax, labeling it “regressive,” while Steyer attributed rising prices to geopolitical tensions, particularly regarding Iran. Becerra argued that reducing the gas tax could jeopardize the state budget and critical infrastructure projects.
Due to the venue being Pomona College, candidates faced direct questions from students. One Marine Corps cadet asked about making California more affordable for graduates, leading to contrasting responses. While one candidate proposed a “pay it forward” tuition model, Hilton was chided for lacking concrete policies despite leaning on his campaign slogan.
This debate marked the first major televised discussion since former Congressman Eric Swalwell exited the race. Analysts suggested that Becerra’s absence created an opportunity for both him and Steyer to challenge one another’s records instead of addressing Republican contenders directly.
Debate Polling Insights
According to recent polling data post-debate, Steve Hilton holds a narrow lead among Republicans, garnering between 16% to 20% support. Tom Steyer is tied for first with around 15%, benefiting from a substantial self-funded advertising campaign. Becerra experienced a surge in support following Swalwell’s withdrawal but also faced significant scrutiny over his federal record. Chad Bianco remains a strong contender, currently polling between 10% to 17%.
