Peter Navarro, a former senior trade adviser to Donald Trump, is asking the Supreme Court to throw out his convictions for refusing to comply with a congressional subpoena. The case could affect how prosecutors prove that someone knowingly broke the law by defying Congress.
Navarro, now a senior counselor for trade and manufacturing in the Trump administration, was convicted in 2023 on two counts of contempt of Congress. He had refused to provide documents or testify before the House committee investigating Jan. 6, saying he believed executive privilege prevented him from doing so. He served four months in federal prison.
Before trial, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta ruled that Navarro had not shown Trump invoked executive privilege in response to the subpoena, so Navarro could not use that claim as a defense. The D.C. Circuit later upheld the convictions, finding that someone could violate the law even if they sincerely, but mistakenly, believed their refusal was lawful.
The appeals court also said executive privilege can be invoked only by the president. It noted that Navarro claimed privilege before seeing the subpoena and did not turn over records, appear for a deposition, or work with the committee to address his claim.
Navarro’s attorney, Abhishek Kambli, argues the appeals court read the law incorrectly. He points to a 1933 Supreme Court decision, United States v. Murdock, which considered whether a taxpayer’s genuine but mistaken belief that the Constitution protected his refusal to answer investigators was relevant to whether he had acted willfully.
Kambli says the word “willful” in the contempt statute should require prosecutors to establish a person’s state of mind. In his view, that standard could also make it harder to use contempt proceedings against political opponents.
The House voted to hold Navarro in contempt, but Kambli says the Jan. 6 committee skipped the usual process for negotiating disputes with executive branch officials. Those discussions, he said, can help determine how a witness will appear and whether executive privilege applies.
Kambli argues that requiring proof of the appropriate mental state would reduce the number of contempt prosecutions and make it less likely that congressional subpoenas are used for purposes unrelated to legitimate legislative work. He also says a ruling for Navarro could help prevent future political retaliation.
The petition was filed a week before Democratic Sen. Elissa Slotkin called for an investigation into alleged corruption in the Trump administration. After Democrats won the 2026 midterm elections, several lawmakers also posted online about investigating Trump officials. Republicans, however, are set to retain control of both chambers until Democrats take over in January 2027.
Conservative attorney Mike Davis, whose Article III Project filed a brief supporting Navarro, urged the Supreme Court to hear the case. He argued that treating good faith as no defense turns congressional subpoenas into potential criminal traps and undermines long-standing negotiations between the branches of government.
The petition follows the Supreme Court’s action in the case of former Trump adviser Steve Bannon, who also served four months in prison after a contempt conviction tied to a Jan. 6 committee subpoena. In April 2026, the court vacated the D.C. Circuit’s ruling against Bannon and sent the case back for further proceedings after the Justice Department moved to dismiss his indictment.






