Tyler Tolbert Makes History at Citi Field

On a rather dreary Tuesday evening, Tyler Tolbert etched his name in baseball history during a thrilling game at Citi Field.

The outfielder, typically brought in for defensive plays or as a pinch runner, managed an infield hit in the fifth inning. That marked his fifth hit of the night and tied a major league record for the most hits in 12 consecutive at-bats.

Though Tolbert didn’t quite break the record, he concluded his impressive run with a fly-out to right field in the ninth inning, finishing the game with a solid 5-for-6 performance.

The Citi Field crowd erupted in a standing ovation as Tolbert’s teammates celebrated from the dugout’s top row. Later, they clinked champagne bottles in the visiting clubhouse following a 16-12 victory over the Mets.

Tyler Tolbert’s Record-Setting Night

“Honestly, I’m just laughing. I feel thankful for this journey,” Tolbert remarked. “The fans were incredible, cheering me on for more chances. It’s just my teammates, though—they were fully invested. Seeing everyone’s smiles in the dugout honestly warms my heart.”

With this performance, Tolbert tied the record previously established by Johnny Kling back in 1902. The record has seen a few changes over the years, including being broken by Pinky Higgins in 1938, Walt Dropo in 1952, and most recently by Jose Miranda in 2024, now alongside Tolbert.

“I couldn’t be prouder of him. The energy, the effort, and his positive attitude—it elevates everyone,” praised Royals manager Matt Quatraro after the game.

The bat that completed Tolbert’s record-tying feat will find its place in the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, New York, forever marking this moment in baseball history.