Welcome to this made-up world. Your soul isn’t part of the deal.

Welcome to this made-up world. Your soul isn’t part of the deal.

Five years ago, venture capitalist Marc Andreessen made a forceful case for spending a substantial part of life in digital worlds. He argued that a small, fortunate group enjoys rich surroundings and social lives in the physical world, while most people lack that kind of “reality privilege.” For them, online life might be far more engaging and rewarding than what they find offline.

Now, with Anthropic preparing for a record-setting public offering and the latest, highly detailed Grand Theft Auto game arriving, digital environments have become richer than they were in 2021. There’s plenty more on the way, too. It seems like a useful moment to revisit Andreessen’s argument.

He acknowledged at the time that his position could sound bleak to people who were thriving in the real world. They argued that improving actual life should come before building better virtual experiences. Andreessen’s response was that reality had had thousands of years to improve and still failed many people. There was no reason, he said, to wait thousands more before creating online places where people could live, work, and find connection.

During the pandemic, as I started writing a book in defense of reality, I took that argument seriously. It’s not difficult to make a case against humanity; plenty of writers have done so. Joseph Heller captured the basic idea in “Catch-22”: without the spirit, human beings are nothing.

What gives us worth, and makes the body sacred, is the soul: the immortal presence God breathed into us, and continues to sustain. Ignore that, or turn away from it, and human life can seem miserable and even contemptible. The physical world is both overvalued and undervalued, in a way. It’s overvalued when people treat it as separate from the spiritual, and undervalued when they see it as a prison rather than a good creation.

Materialism can lead to the conclusion that reality disappoints because people are bad, while simulated worlds are better because they limit how much harm we can do. From that perspective, simulation is the highest achievement of human intelligence: a way to reduce our worst tendencies. That’s partly why I’ve argued that “artificial intelligence” is a misleading term. These systems might be better described as automated simulators, a phrase already familiar in video games.

Christian teaching, including traditions reaching back to the Desert Fathers, draws a distinction between the physical and spiritual dimensions of reality. It also sets limits on what intelligence can do. Intellect lets us reason about God, for example, while the soul’s nous is understood as a higher faculty that allows us to know God. Intelligence without that faculty can’t fully grasp reality. It can imitate it, but only so far.

Those imitations don’t necessarily feel thin or disappointing to our senses. They can be astonishing. Claude may give the impression of talking with someone who knows everything and understands you completely. Grand Theft Auto can make its virtual world seem more full of meaning and excitement than ordinary work and daily routines.

But automated simulations can also make life feel pleasantly smaller, less complicated and less significant. There’s a strange spiritual comfort in switching to autopilot, especially when the world around us is built to keep us from wondering whether that ease comes at some cost to the soul.

Early reactions to Grand Theft Auto VI point to that tension. One post joked about people watching television inside a video game while streaming it to others who are watching them play. Another popular account called the game a chore simulator: realistic, absorbing, but tedious and not much fun.

In an essay about the game, Joe Bernstein asked how anyone could simulate a country that already seems detached from reality. Maybe the more revealing question is what both Anthropic and Rockstar appear to see as a flaw in virtual worlds: too much fun, and too little virtue. Their products suggest that online life may increasingly ask people to practice becoming good, even when they would rather just play.

You may find yourself being drawn into that simulated future. But it isn’t exactly a game.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News