A new analysis of the Democrats’ midterm gains suggests the party’s “blue wave” was driven mostly by turnout, rather than voters switching sides.
A J.L. Partners report published Monday found that Democrats would have won both chambers of Congress even if no voters had moved from the Republican column to the Democratic one.
Many of the non-college-educated, rural and retired voters who backed Donald Trump in 2024 stayed home, the report said, weakening the Republican majority before defections were factored in.
Just 52% of Trump’s 2024 voters turned out to support House Republicans in 2026. Another 35% did not vote, while 8% backed House Democrats. The analysis estimated that turnout accounted for about two-thirds of the Democrats’ gains.
Younger Trump voters were more likely to switch parties than older ones. Among voters aged 18 to 29, 16% crossed over to the Democrats, compared with 4% of those aged 50 to 64.
J.L. Partners founding director James Johnson said Republicans should not abandon Trump-aligned politics. He argued that energizing the coalition that supported Trump in 2024 could give the party a chance to win again in 2028.
The report also found that half of those who switched from Trump to a Democrat in 2026 still viewed the Republican Party favorably, suggesting some might be persuaded to return.
For midterm voters, the cost of living and the economy were the leading concerns. Corruption ranked third, and no other issue was named by more than 9% of voters.
Johnson said voters who left Trump were not necessarily looking for a return to traditional Republican politics. According to the report, they were drawn to the Democratic Socialists of America and included younger, nonwhite men who had supported Trump for the first time in 2024.
The analysis also found limited appetite among Democratic voters for impeaching the president: only 16% said it was a top priority.




