Wife and daughter arrested after DNA identifies the man whose severed head was found in a trash bag

Wife and daughter arrested after DNA identifies the man whose severed head was found in a trash bag

A California woman and her daughter have been arrested more than four years after a dog walker discovered a man’s severed head inside a trash bag, authorities said.

The Placer County Sheriff’s Office identified the man as Paul Wesley Fitzmaurice Jr., 73. He had not been reported missing, and investigators say his wife and daughter told relatives he was still alive.

Mary Fitzmaurice, 45, and her mother, Georgia “Gwenn” Fitzmaurice, 75, were booked into South Placer Jail on Tuesday. Mary was arrested on suspicion of murder, while Gwenn was booked on suspicion of being an accessory, officials said.

At a news conference Wednesday, Placer County Sheriff Wayne Woo said the women maintained the appearance that Paul was alive, telling family and friends he was still around. Authorities say they continued collecting his Social Security benefits and California public pension after his death.

Woo said the women told some of Paul’s estranged relatives that he was a recluse who sometimes disappeared for days. They claimed he returned home about once a week and stayed for a few days, he said.

The sheriff’s office alleges Mary killed her father and that the two women conspired to dispose of his remains. District Attorney Morgan Gire said prosecutors expected to file a murder charge against Mary by the end of Wednesday. They were also considering other charges connected to the death and the benefits collected in Paul’s name.

Asked if money may have been a motive, Woo said investigators still had substantial work to do and that any answer would be speculation at this stage.

The dog walker found the bag on Sept. 28, 2022, in the Todd Valley area of Foresthill, as the Mosquito Fire burned nearby. Woo said the discovery received little attention at the time.

“The people who didn’t forget about this case were Foresthill residents and our cold case detectives,” he said.

The remains were too decomposed for investigators to identify the man. Forensic experts at California State University, Chico, created an artist’s rendering, but it did not lead to a match in missing-person records. A search of the national law enforcement DNA database also found no match.

In January 2024, detectives sent a DNA sample to Othram Labs. The lab used forensic genetic genealogy to identify possible distant relatives. With help from the FBI, investigators traced the family tree and obtained a DNA sample from a relative in another state, which helped confirm Fitzmaurice’s identity.

Othram said the identification was the 94th publicly announced California case in which investigators had used its technology to identify someone.

Investigators believe Mary killed her father at the family’s home in Citrus Heights. Detectives searched the property Tuesday with help from the FBI. Asked where Fitzmaurice was killed, Woo said evidence gathered during the search might help determine that.

His remaining remains have not been found. “We did not find any remains at the residence yesterday,” Woo said.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News