Dispute Over Sales at American Dream Mall
The American Dream Mall in New Jersey offers a variety of attractions, including indoor skiing, artificial surfing, and roller coasters. However, it’s currently facing legal challenges that aren’t exactly thrilling. A lawsuit has emerged from Paramus, claiming the mall has been flouting county laws that prohibit the sale of non-essential items—like clothing and appliances—on Sundays.
These “blue laws,” which can be traced back to religious practices centuries ago, are intended to provide some respite from the usual hustle and bustle, particularly for residents near New York City. In Paramus, a notable shopping area with several malls, almost all retailers are closed on Sundays, creating a quieter atmosphere.
The American Dream, launched in 2019 next to MetLife Stadium—home of the NFL’s Jets and Giants—initially planned to keep retailers closed on Sundays. Still, it turns out many have been operating instead. According to a report from January, these retailers have been open for nearly a year.
The lawsuit contends that mall operators have violated the law repeatedly, possibly “hundreds, if not thousands, of times” since January, aided by mall ownership. The American Dream management argues that the blue laws don’t apply because it’s on state property.
City officials, however, including Paramus Mayor Christopher Dipiazza, emphasize their commitment to upholding these laws. In past discussions, the mall’s vice president had stated intentions to limit retail activities on Sundays.
Bergen County Executive Jim Tedesco, also named in the lawsuit, remarked that the mall management assured him that retailers would remain closed on Sundays. He criticized the decision to operate on that day as not only illegal but also as providing an unfair edge over other local businesses that comply with the regulations.
The lawsuit’s outcomes remain uncertain, particularly since East Rutherford officials have not publicly responded, and neither has the New Jersey State Attorney General’s office, as the matter is still pending. Historically, New Jersey’s blue laws were much more comprehensive, impacting not just retail but also recreational activities.
Despite a trend of easing restrictions throughout much of the state, Bergen County leaders have consistently opposed efforts to repeal these laws, with some exemptions for food stores being supported by local voters.
