Syracuse student describes Thanksgiving as a ‘celebration of genocide’ in an opinion piece

Syracuse University Student Calls Thanksgiving a “Celebration of Genocide”

A student at Syracuse University expressed a controversial view in the campus newspaper, the Daily Orange, claiming that Thanksgiving symbolizes the celebration of genocide. Mateo López Castro stated, “Thanksgiving is essentially a celebration of genocide.” He argues that this perspective is crucial for understanding American cultural foundations, suggesting that without acknowledging these historical truths, traditional American identity would be undermined.

López Castro referenced the John Sullivan movement, mentioning that during the American Revolution, the choice was made for “mass annihilation” of Indigenous peoples rather than pursuing peaceful resolutions. This decision, he argues, laid the groundwork for “the expansion of settler colonialism.”

He further pointed out that American media often glorifies slavery and “white supremacy,” suggesting that movies like “Gone with the Wind” mask the historical realities surrounding these themes. “Our entire society was and continues to be built on genocide,” he wrote, emphasizing that this acknowledgment is essential.

López Castro highlighted how recent American media, including the series “Yellowstone” and the film “The Ballad of Buster Scruggs,” tend to overlook the accurate portrayal of Indigenous peoples in history. He also criticized the Trump administration for allegedly attempting to suppress the truth regarding the genocide of the Palestinian people, calling attention to how manipulation of the media can distort historical narratives.

He urged Americans to engage in education that challenges established notions of American culture and to strive for transformation. Various universities and school districts have echoed similar sentiments, with events occurring across the country to acknowledge a “day of remembrance” instead of celebrating Thanksgiving. This initiative focuses on recognizing the “decolonization” of Thanksgiving, reinforcing the call for deeper understanding and remembrance of Indigenous histories.