A primary school in Michigan has changed its stance after reports emerged that two Christian students were not allowed to perform worship songs at an upcoming talent show.
In a statement shared with media, Principal James Antoine acknowledged that the staff lacked understanding of legal guidelines regarding religious expression in public schools. He confirmed that religious songs are permitted at school events like talent shows.
According to legal sources, two brothers from Westward Elementary were informed by staff that their song choices—“I’m Praise” by Brandon Lake and “Up and Up” by Colton Dixon—could not be performed. A teacher reportedly indicated that one song was “Christian-based” and, thus, breached the separation of church and state.
Principal Molly Carl expressed concerns about the lyrics, suggesting they might raise issues for some due to references to worshiping God. She specifically highlighted a line related to the Israelites’ escape from Egypt—a biblical story from Exodus.
Carl had also questioned one student about her song choices, implying a lack of belief in God among her peers.
Despite initially approving the songs before auditions, Carl later advised one student to consider adjusting his selection for the talent show to something “more acceptable.”
The legal group, First Liberty Institute, sent a letter to the school warning that the students’ rights were being infringed upon.
The organization urged the school to allow the brothers to perform their chosen songs on equal footing with other participants.
Following this, the school reassured legal representatives that songs with religious lyrics would be permitted at the talent show. The district acknowledged that staff was not fully aware of the protections for religious expression in public schools.
In their response, Allegan Public Schools clarified that students are allowed to perform songs of their choice, including those with religious themes, provided they meet the school’s conduct standards.
They expressed relief that the matter had been resolved quickly, ensuring students would have the chance to audition and perform.
The district also pledged to improve internal communication procedures to prevent similar misunderstandings in the future and regretted any confusion caused to students and families.
Kayla Tony from First Liberty expressed gratitude to the school for their swift action in recognizing students’ religious rights.
Legal advocates suggested that the school participate in a training program to better understand how to promote religious freedom for all students.
