Investors question DOJ stance on lawsuit over failed solar project
The Trump administration has made fighting fraud and government waste a priority, including offering financial rewards to people who report wrongdoing. But investors in a failed solar project from the Obama era are asking why the Justice Department is defending the dismissal of their lawsuit over a $275 million federal grant. They say the case could potentially return as much as $1 billion to taxpayers.
The investors allege that companies connected to Spanish construction firm ACS misled federal officials to obtain the grant, claiming the plant was ready for use despite serious construction problems. The facility was later shut down for months after a failure in its molten-salt storage tank.
The dispute involves Crescent Dunes, a billion-dollar solar project backed by the federal government. It began operating in Nevada in 2015, then suffered engineering problems, repeated shutdowns and two bankruptcies. Its assets were sold for just $7 million in July.
The plant used thousands of mirrors to focus sunlight on a tall receiver, heating molten salt. That heat could be stored and used to produce electricity after sunset.
In 2020, a group of private investors who had put $90 million into the project filed a whistleblower lawsuit, claiming the companies had deceived the government to secure the grant. In November 2024, two days after Donald Trump won the presidential election, the Biden administration’s Justice Department asked a court to dismiss the case, arguing that continuing it would burden federal agencies.
The incoming Trump administration could have changed course after taking office. Instead, in April 2025, its Justice Department defended the dismissal in an appeals court filing.
CMB, the investment group led by Pat Hogan, is appealing the decision. Hogan has also asked the Trump administration’s Justice Department to support reopening the case, but says he has received no commitment.
Hogan said he sees little sense in the government’s position. He argues the case concerns a foreign company taking advantage of federal funds, and that the government has an opportunity to address it.
Under the False Claims Act, the law CMB relied on, companies found liable may have to pay up to three times the government’s proven losses, along with additional penalties. Hogan believes the potential recovery could reach $1 billion.
Tonopah Solar Energy, the plant’s former owner and one of the defendants, has called CMB’s allegations baseless in court filings. Other defendants have also supported the Justice Department’s effort to dismiss the suit.
In an April 2026 filing, the Justice Department again defended the Biden administration’s decision, arguing that the government has broad authority to end such cases and that continuing this one would consume agency resources. Neither administration has specified in court how much the litigation would cost to pursue.
The dispute has left Hogan and his investors asking why the government moved to stop the case, and what Treasury officials knew about the plant’s problems when they approved the grant.
A central question is whether Crescent Dunes had been properly completed and whether Tonopah Solar Energy qualified to receive the $275 million in Treasury funding. The grant was part of a $26 billion program within the Obama administration’s larger $90 billion clean-energy initiative, created under the 2009 economic stimulus package.
The program, known as Section 1603, reimbursed developers for about 30% of eligible construction costs once facilities were “placed in service”—that is, ready and available for their intended use. Treasury considered factors including whether a plant had passed key tests, begun producing electricity and been placed under its owner’s control.
Crescent Dunes started generating electricity in 2015. CMB says it produced no more than 32% of its expected output through June 2016. In October of that year, a failure in the hot molten-salt tank forced the plant offline for months.
In December, while the facility was still shut down, builder Cobra Thermosolar Plants formally transferred it to Tonopah Solar Energy under an arrangement called “provisional acceptance.” The companies had first revised their construction contract to permit the handover despite significant defects and incomplete repairs. The agreement came only days before the year-end deadline for solar projects to be ready for use to qualify for Treasury grants.
CMB later alleged that inspectors had identified more than 9,000 defects, grouped into about 500 outstanding construction items, including seven major deficiencies. The investors say those problems meant the plant was not ready to be handed over.
The December agreement acknowledged that repairs to the failed molten-salt tank were still required. The tank was essential to storing solar heat so the plant could continue producing electricity after dark. CMB alleges that the revised agreement made the facility appear ready for use so the companies could obtain the grant, even though major issues remained.
Records indicate that Treasury had questioned the plant’s readiness months before approving the grant. In September 2016, the department challenged Tonopah’s claim that the facility had been ready since February. Treasury cited a commissioning report from July that suggested Cobra had not yet formally transferred control of the plant.
Tonopah responded on September 21, arguing that the plant had passed important tests and could generate electricity. It also acknowledged an earlier extended shutdown caused by problems with the salt-piping system. The following month, the storage tank failed, taking the plant offline for months. Despite the breakdown, Tonopah and Cobra proceeded with their revised handover agreement in December.
On March 7, 2017, during the first Trump administration, Treasury approved an initial grant payment of $243.7 million. Crescent Dunes was still shut down, nearly five months after the tank failure, and would not resume producing electricity until July. Treasury’s approval letter said it was still reviewing some of the project’s claimed costs before deciding whether to release further funds.
In February 2018, Treasury approved another $31.9 million, bringing the total grant to about $275.6 million, according to federal records. The additional payment was due to be issued within seven business days.
The Energy Department was also involved. It had backed the project with a $737 million federal loan guarantee and approved the revised December handover despite outstanding repairs. The department also waived certain missed deadlines, allowing the project to be considered operational under its loan agreement. That decision did not automatically make the plant eligible for the separate Treasury grant.
A financing agreement between Tonopah and the Energy Department required the Treasury grant to be used first to repay short-term federal borrowing, including principal and accrued interest. Records show Tonopah paid $218.9 million toward a federal loan in March 2017, shortly after Treasury approved the initial grant.
Hogan said that, in effect, the government had paid itself, while still bearing the project’s losses. In April 2017, while Crescent Dunes remained offline, the Energy Department published a post praising the plant as a solar-technology breakthrough without mentioning its months-long shutdown.
It remains unclear whether Treasury officials knew about the tank failure, outstanding repairs and contract changes when they approved the first grant payment. That information could have affected the plant’s eligibility. The Energy and Treasury departments have been asked about the approval process, the plant’s condition and potential losses, but have not provided a complete account.
In a statement, the Energy Department criticized earlier administrations’ handling of the project and said it had resolved its financial interests in Crescent Dunes in 2020. The department said it has had no ownership, operational or financial interest in the project since then.
In January 2020, CMB sued Tonopah Solar Energy and companies linked to ACS. The investors had lent $90 million to a company connected to Crescent Dunes developer SolarReserve and alleged that the defendants defrauded the federal government.
The False Claims Act allows private whistleblowers to sue on the government’s behalf and receive part of any money recovered. These cases, known as qui tam actions, may be taken over or dismissed by the Justice Department.
After investigating CMB’s allegations for more than three years, the Biden administration declined to take over the suit in June 2023, leaving the investors to pursue it themselves. On November 7, 2024, the department sought dismissal, saying the case would burden the Treasury, Energy and Justice departments.
CMB challenged that request, arguing the department had not explained what had changed since it had allowed the investors to continue. In July 2025, a federal judge granted the Justice Department’s request and dismissed the suit without ruling on whether the fraud allegations were true. CMB appealed, and the Trump administration defended the dismissal in an April 2026 filing before the Ninth Circuit.
Matt Dunn, a lawyer who works on False Claims Act cases, described the Justice Department’s decision to step in after initially allowing the suit to proceed as unusual, though not unheard of. He said the government may assess a case’s merits or potential value differently from the whistleblower, and may not share that assessment publicly.
Dunn also noted that the Supreme Court has given the government substantial discretion to dismiss these cases, making it very difficult for whistleblowers to overturn such a decision.
Hogan has a financial interest in the outcome: he says his investors lost the $90 million they lent to the SolarReserve-linked company. If the case is revived and CMB wins, the government could theoretically recover up to three times its proven losses, while CMB could receive a share that might help offset the investors’ losses. Hogan said he sees it as his responsibility to pursue every available avenue to get their money back.
The Ninth Circuit must now decide whether the lawsuit can proceed or whether the Justice Department’s dismissal will stand. If the case moves forward, it could give the government a chance to recover a substantial amount of disputed funds.
The case has also prompted questions from lawmakers. In February 2025, Representatives Lance Gooden of Texas and Carol Miller of West Virginia urged Attorney General Pam Bondi to investigate the Biden administration’s decision to seek dismissal.
Gooden later asked Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to consider suspending federal contracts with companies connected to ACS, whose subsidiary Cobra built Crescent Dunes and held a stake in Tonopah. He also called for an investigation into ACS and Banco Santander’s roles in the project’s financing and bankruptcy, in light of the fraud allegations.
Gooden said the government should establish what happened and hold responsible parties to account. He asked Hegseth to pause contracts with ACS-linked entities until the allegations were reviewed and efforts to recover taxpayer money had been pursued.
One contract involves a $2.84 billion Navy dry-dock project at Pearl Harbor awarded to a joint venture that includes ACS subsidiary Dragados. The Government Accountability Office says the expected completion date has shifted from September 2027 to March 2029. Dragados is not accused of fraud in the Crescent Dunes lawsuit.
Miller questioned how a project supported by nearly $1 billion in federal financing could ultimately sell for $7 million. She said the figures did not add up and suggested another congressional letter might be appropriate, adding that recovering any taxpayer funds would be welcome.
In April 2026, Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley of Iowa sought answers from the Justice Department about its handling of fraud cases, particularly lawsuits it had dismissed despite whistleblowers wanting to proceed.
In a July 10 response, the department said Crescent Dunes was one of 12 cases in which it sought dismissal after initially allowing the suit to go forward. That represented less than 0.3% of nearly 5,000 whistleblower cases received from 2020 through 2025.
The department also confirmed that other federal agencies may seek dismissal of these cases, including to avoid the burden of producing evidence. It did not say whether Treasury or the Energy Department had pushed to end the Crescent Dunes suit, or what investigators found in reviewing the allegations.
The defendants have backed the Justice Department’s position, arguing that federal law gives the government broad power to dismiss whistleblower cases. Tonopah, which filed for bankruptcy in January 2026, has strongly denied CMB’s claims and accused the investors of pursuing an aggressive campaign through repeated legal challenges.
In an April 2026 bankruptcy filing, Tonopah said it believed CMB’s claims had no merit. The company made that argument as it wound down its affairs and prepared to sell the plant’s assets in July. The new owners were not involved in the alleged 2016 fraud, and the bankruptcy sale generally protected them from the former owner’s legal liabilities.
In a separate 2020 lawsuit, Hogan’s investors sought repayment of a purportedly unpaid $90 million loan after SolarReserve failed to return much of the money. They suffered a setback in 2024, when an arbitration panel rejected five claims and ordered them to pay $2.44 million in legal fees and costs. That dispute was separate from the whistleblower case over the Treasury grant.
The companies did not respond to repeated requests for comment. The Justice Department has not publicly disclosed what its investigation found.
Almost seven years after the investors filed their case, the fraud allegations have not been tested at trial. And although President Trump has promised to pursue fraud and wasteful green-energy spending, his Justice Department continues to defend the decision to dismiss the lawsuit.
Hogan said that if the investors are wrong, the evidence will show it, but argued that a dismissal made under the Biden administration should not prevent the allegations from ever being heard.






