New York’s Budget Proposal Targets Immigration Enforcement
Governor Kathy Hochul of New York has introduced a budget request for fiscal year 2027 that includes new measures aimed at limiting the authority of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency. The goal is to challenge the federal agency’s power, although experts predict that the initiative might face significant obstacles from the outset.
The proposed Local Police Local Crimes Act would curb local police cooperation with ICE. Hochul, aligned with broader Democratic efforts to counteract former President Donald Trump’s stringent immigration policies, states that local law enforcement should prioritize community safety instead of federal mandates.
“ICE will no longer be able to leverage police and penal institutions for immigration enforcement tasks,” Hochul expressed at a press conference. “Local resources should be used to protect communities and handle everyday public safety issues, not immigration.”
Despite her intentions, some have critiqued Hochul’s approach. For instance, while she labels ICE actions as “cruel,” some argue that certain detainees may pose risks to public safety, particularly children.
The Local Police Local Crimes Act seeks to annul the extension of agreements under the 287(g) program, which traditionally permits local law enforcement to engage in immigration-related duties. It outlines numerous reforms, including a provision for residents to sue ICE for constitutional violations and bans on law enforcement from wearing masks during operations. Access restrictions would also be implemented, prohibiting ICE from entering schools, libraries, and homes without judicial approval.
Legal expert Hans von Spakovsky has voiced skepticism about the longevity of these changes. He refers to historical legal precedents indicating states are typically unable to impede federal officials in executing their responsibilities. The act emphasizes that local law enforcement must still comply with valid immigration warrants issued by courts.
Lorin Biss, acting assistant secretary for public affairs at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), criticized Hochul’s stance, claiming it jeopardizes public safety in New York City. He argued that preventing local enforcement from cooperating with federal agencies could lead to more violent offenders being released back into communities.
Interestingly, Hochul’s office did not address inquiries regarding the state’s position on detaining those suspected of immigration violations or the relevance of the Local Police Community Crime Act within the 2027 budget proposal.
