Ian Murray says he always thought he was a U.S. citizen, so the immigration court notice he received last July came as a shock.
Murray, 75, spent more than five decades as a prominent Democratic Party figure in Erie County, Pennsylvania. He worked on George McGovern’s 1972 presidential campaign there, served four years on Erie City Council in the early 2000s, and represented Pennsylvania on the Democratic National Committee from 1982 to 2020.
Federal officials said he had not been admitted or paroled into the United States. Murray believed he was a citizen because his mother held dual Canadian and U.S. citizenship when he moved to the country as a child about 70 years ago.
But when he applied for a passport, officials reviewed his status and found that his mother had not lived in the United States for the 10 years before his birth. Under a provision of the Nationality Act of 1940, that meant Murray did not acquire U.S. citizenship through her.
“I can’t believe this is happening,” he said. He later described the experience as feeling almost like he was being erased.
Murray had retired to Maine. Rather than face removal proceedings, he and his wife moved to Canada on November 12. He said he had a Social Security card and had even obtained a REAL ID in Maine.
His mother had spent four years studying at the University of Toronto before he was born, Murray said, leaving her short of the required period of U.S. residency. After trying to challenge the decision, he was told by immigration lawyers that he had no legal status in the country.
“If I had never applied for a passport, I would never have been deported,” he said.
Murray was granted permission to leave voluntarily. He said he sold his home quickly and obtained an emergency Canadian passport before moving to Nova Scotia.
“We are starting a new chapter,” he said.




