Judge refuses Alex Murdaugh’s request to drop murder charges over claims about blood and ammunition

Judge refuses Alex Murdaugh’s request to drop murder charges over claims about blood and ammunition

A judge overseeing Alex Murdaugh’s double-murder retrial has declined to dismiss the charges, handing the former attorney another setback before his case returns to court.

At a pretrial hearing Nov. 13, Murdaugh’s lawyers argued that South Carolina Law Enforcement Division investigator David Owen misled the grand jury about blood-spatter evidence and shotgun ammunition. They said the testimony compromised the indictment process.

South Carolina Circuit Court Judge Debra R. McCaslin acknowledged that the state’s presentation to the grand jury included significant errors. Still, she said the remaining evidence was more than enough to support the indictment, even if the disputed testimony were set aside.

McCaslin criticized Owen for failing to account for a laboratory report sent directly to him before he testified. She said mistakes of that kind can damage public confidence in the justice system.

The judge also found that the information presented about ammunition was inaccurate, but said the record did not show that Owen deliberately fabricated evidence or that prosecutors engaged in misconduct.

Murdaugh’s attorneys will be able to challenge the disputed evidence at trial, McCaslin said. Inconsistencies in investigative statements and forensic conclusions, she wrote, should be addressed through cross-examination rather than by dismissing the indictments.

The defense said Owen gave the grand jury a misleading account of alleged blood spatter on a shirt Murdaugh wore on June 7, 2021, the day his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, were killed at the family’s Moselle property in Colleton County.

Owen testified that blood spatter on the shirt connected Murdaugh to the killings, although earlier testing had not detected human blood in samples from the garment. During Murdaugh’s first murder trial, Owen said he had not intended to mislead the grand jury and had not seen the final laboratory report until after the indictment was issued.

Prosecutors argued at the latest hearing that the negative blood tests did not necessarily disprove the blood-spatter findings. They also cited later testing by a state expert, who said prior chemical treatment could have caused false-negative results. Prosecutors said the expert stood by his conclusions and that Owen had described investigators’ understanding of the evidence at the time.

The defense also disputed Owen’s testimony that shotguns recovered from the property contained the same combination of ammunition used to kill Paul. Murdaugh’s lawyers said none of the recovered shotguns held the exact combination of shells found at the scene.

Prosecutors conceded that Owen may have described the ammunition imprecisely, but said he had not knowingly misled the grand jury. Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters said the testimony reflected what Owen understood at the time.

Murdaugh was convicted of both murders in 2023. The South Carolina Supreme Court later overturned the convictions, finding that former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill had improperly influenced the jury. The retrial is scheduled to begin April 5, 2027.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News