A federal judge in Maine ruled Friday that the Hermon School Committee discriminated against The Pines Church of Bangor after the church sought to rent Hermon High School for Sunday services. The judge found that religious bias played a role in the committee’s decision.
In 2022, lead pastor Matt Gioia contacted the Hermon School Department about renting space at the high school. He asked for a yearlong lease rather than a month-to-month arrangement.
After Gioia presented the proposal to the school committee, member Christopher McLaughlin sent questions through then-Superintendent Micah Grant. The questions asked how the church addressed diversity, equity and inclusion, particularly in its positions on same-sex marriage, abortion and transgender issues.
Grant later forwarded the questions to Gioia and apologized. He and committee Chair Jesse Keith also sought legal advice about whether approving the lease could amount to an unlawful establishment of religion, and whether denying it might violate the First Amendment.
Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker said he did not find that Grant had shown bias, noting that the superintendent repeatedly helped Gioia with the application process. But Walker concluded that at least three committee members—McLaughlin, Stephanie Oiler and Karen Shorey—were improperly influenced by the church’s religious identity or beliefs.
Walker wrote that McLaughlin appeared to base his decision on the church’s religious beliefs, related political and cultural views, and the religious nature of its proposed use of the school. The judge said McLaughlin would have handled the request differently if it had come from an organization whose beliefs matched his own.
Discussing Oiler’s conduct, Walker said he found it showed a sufficiently improper motive under First Amendment standards.
The judge ruled that the school department violated the church’s First Amendment rights and Maine’s public accommodations law by denying its request for a yearlong lease.
Walker declined, however, to order the school department to stop future lease denials. He said the church had not shown that the written rental policy itself was unconstitutional or met the legal requirements for an injunction, including proof of irreparable harm.
Hermon School Superintendent Barbara Sargent said the department was reviewing the decision and would consider whether its procedures needed changes. She said the department remained focused on students, staff and providing a strong educational environment.
The church and the legal group representing it did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
In a statement, Advocates for Faith & Freedom called the ruling a victory for religious liberty. The group’s president, Bob Tyler, said public schools that make facilities available to community organizations should not exclude churches because of their faith. He said the court found that concerns about staffing, capacity and logistics were not the real reason for the denial, and argued that the decision upheld the constitutional requirement of neutrality.






