Media have misinterpreted former President Donald Trump's remarks to Jewish voters at the Israeli-American Council on Thursday night, falsely claiming he was scapegoating Jews, when in fact he was urging Jews to vote for him.
As Breitbart News noted, Trump noted that despite all his work for Israel, his approval rating has only risen from 25% to 29% (other estimates put it at 24% to 30.5%), and called on Jewish voters to boost Republican support within their community.
Trump noted that his approval rating among Jews will be high at 40% in 2024, but that the vast majority of Jews intend to vote for the Democrats out of “habit”, a party that remains anti-Israel and allows anti-Semitism to flourish.
of The New York TimesOthers misinterpreted Trump's comments, claiming he was suggesting a Jewish conspiracy would be to blame if he lost the election — at an event aimed at combating anti-Semitism. TimesThe headline read: “At an event condemning anti-Semitism, Donald Trump said 'Jews will bear a lot of the blame' if he loses.” article He repeated false claims that Trump is anti-Semitic.
update: One anti-Trump attendee pointed out that the media had completely distorted the content of Trump's speech.
Below are Trump's actual words from that portion of the speech (video below), with the parts that are deemed offensive highlighted in context.
C-SPAN
Now, I did all these things and got a 29% approval rating. Think about it. So I was wronged. But it's not me who was wronged. It's Israel. Because the vote can make a big difference. It's going to be a big factor in the vote. I have to say Miami and other places were great. But honestly, I went from 25 to 29. Based on what I've done and my love for the same love that you guys have, I should be 100. I should be 100. [Applause] But I'm going to give you the bad news. The polls. I told you how good the polls are, and we need every vote we can get. The polls right now say that I am a Jewish citizen, a Jewish person, a person who should love Israel, and I was the best president ever, by far the best president ever. My approval rating is 40%. That means 60% of people are voting for someone who hates Israel. I say this. It's going to happen. And it's only because the Democrats are controlling you, cursing you. This can't happen. 40% is unacceptable, because we have to win the election. After all of this, my approval rating went down from 29% to 40%. And wise people said to me. My friend, my Jewish friend, he loves Israel, he loves everything about your religion, your country, your place. He said, “I can't believe this is happening. It's so sad.” And he started crying. Actually, he started crying over all of this. He's a tough guy. I don't think he cried because he was a little baby. Maybe I didn't cry then. Maybe I didn't cry then, Miriam. [Adelson]But let me put it very simply and gently. I have been really wronged, and you have been wronged, because you are in great danger. And the United States has been wronged. So if I don't win this election, and I've done very good things, you know, they say Trump was right on every point. I was right on many points. Even Ted would admit that, but I was right on many points. A lot of things that a lot of people said, “That's not going to happen,” but a lot of bad things happened, and some good things that I was right on. And I just hope that it will be. So I wouldn't call it a prophecy. But in my opinion, the Jews have a lot to do with this loss. If I'm 40%, think about that. That means 60% are voting for Kamala. Kamala is a particularly bad Democrat. Democrats are bad for Israel. Very bad. They're never going to change because part of their party has now become incredibly powerful in terms of votes, incredibly quickly. Chuck Schumer is Palestinian. Who would have thought that would happen? What on earth happened to him? [Applause, laughter] I saw him the other day. He was wearing a Hamas robe. That's what's coming next. Chuck Schumer is totally Hamas. I don't know what the hell happened to him. Anyone who supports him is crazy. I haven't seen that he could be any bigger a change than Kamala on fracking in Pennsylvania. Look? But if we don't win this election, in my opinion, Israel will not exist within a couple of years. It will be gone. It's going to happen. It's hard to say. But what would be different from where I stand? I have to tell you the truth. And maybe it will cheer you up to know that I'm not going to get 40% of the vote. I'm the one who's protecting you. These are the people who are trying to destroy you, and you're essentially 60% of the Jewish people voting for them. If I win, Israel will be safe and secure, and we'll be able to stop the poison of anti-Semitism from spreading throughout America and throughout the world. But if I don't win, Israel will be eradicated. I cannot and will not allow that to happen. So, Rabbi, I need to get everyone together and vote, because it's insane to say that I have a 40% approval rating. And when I heard that number today, and it was just released today, I thought that this number is an insult to our country. It's an insult to Israel. And it's very interesting, they did a poll in Israel, and I have a 99% approval rating, and I can run for any office in Israel right now. [Applause] In Israel, everybody loves me. Not so much here, Miriam, but in Israel, everybody loves me. I am 99%. Everyone loves me. I could run for prime minister. Will you make me your prime minister? But I have to learn your language. It is a difficult language. I have to learn it in about three months. I have to learn it very quickly. But I am the most popular person in Israel, and it doesn't work here. It's strange. So we have to save Israel. Look, you are here for a reason. We have to save Israel. This is not a game anymore. This is about saving Israel.
The supposedly anti-Semitic message was applauded by the Jews and Israelis who were present.
People hold banners as former Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks during the Israeli-American Council National Summit in Washington, Thursday, Sept. 19, 2024. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)
But, as usual, his comments were misreported by the media, again suggesting that Trump is an anti-Semite – even after he promised in his speech to eradicate anti-Semitism from college campuses and protect Israel.
Trump's argument is that Jewish voters could decide the election, and that if Trump votes for Kamala Harris, despite everything he has done, he will be putting both Israel and himself at risk.
Trump has made similar remarks to other groups of voters when speculating about the consequences if he were to lose the election, especially with himself or his preferred candidate trailing in the polls.
For example, in 2019, at a rally for Matt Bevin, the Republican gubernatorial candidate who lost to Democrat Andy Beshear in Kentucky, he said“You have to vote, because if you lose it sends a really bad message… and they're going to spread that. If you win they're going to make it a big deal, and if you lose they're going to say Trump suffered the biggest defeat in the history of the world…”
“You can't let that happen to me, you can't let that happen to the great state of Kentucky. You can't let that happen. It would be a disaster for you, too.”
Similarly, Rally During a 2020 speech in New Mexico, after reviewing his accomplishments in the state, he said: “New Mexico is doing better than any state in the United States. How can we lose New Mexico? Please explain to me. How could we lose it?”
Trump says no differently to Jews than he does to any other group of voters he wants to motivate, especially after he gets their way on policy issues that matter to them.
As usual, the media misinterpreted what he said.
Joel B. Pollack is executive editor of Breitbart News. Breitbart News Sunday It airs Sundays from 7:00pm-10:00pm ET (4:00pm-7:00pm PT) on SiriusXM Patriot. He is the author of the following books: Agenda: What President Trump Should Do in His First 100 Daysavailable for pre-order on Amazon. He also Trumpian virtues: The lessons and legacy of Donald Trump's presidencyavailable now on Audible. He is the recipient of the 2018 Robert Novak Journalism Alumni Fellowship. Follow him on Twitter. Joel Pollack.
