Frustration Over Foul Odor in Staten Island

Residents of Staten Island have been grappling with a persistent, unpleasant smell that has lingered for months, causing nausea and irritation, prompting some to leave their homes in search of relief.

Locals in Bull’s Head are seeking answers, as roadwork on Merrill Street completed in December seems to have unleashed a foul odor that permeates their neighborhoods. Many are eager to find a solution to reclaim the fresh air they once took for granted.

Amity Nigro described the odor as reminiscent of “rotten eggs, gas, and sewage.” She expressed frustration, stating, “We are suffering. Our children are suffering.”

Despite her attempts to combat the smell with scented candles, air purifiers, and sealing her doors, the strong odor continued to invade her home.

Deborah Phelps Seda reported that the stench has forced her and her children out of their residence multiple times, leaving her feeling “helpless.” She shared, “I had to evacuate five times because the smell burned my eyes, made me nauseous, and gave me a headache,” mentioning that she learned in December that the odor was suspected to be sewer-related.

The city’s Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) has inspected and cleaned the sewer system, but the noxious smell has yet to dissipate, and officials haven’t ruled out a potential gas leak. There were reports that the odor was coming from the sewer during the roadworks.

In response to the ongoing issue, the DEP announced plans to install filtration devices in manholes to help control odors and engage in wastewater monitoring and air sampling. However, they maintain that the sewers are operating correctly as they continue to investigate the source of the smell.

City Councilman David Carr has reached out to the City Health Department to evaluate how the unusual odor is affecting the health of residents, stating, “I think we need a new perspective.” He noted that many have voiced concerns about painful health symptoms.