An elderly homeowner’s hired help becomes a nightmare after refusing to leave, made worse by laws in a Democratic-led state

An elderly homeowner’s hired help becomes a nightmare after refusing to leave, made worse by laws in a Democratic-led state

California homeowner says fake plumber took over her house and rented out rooms

A 76-year-old San Diego woman says a man she hired to repair pipes took control of her home and began renting rooms to more than a dozen people, some of whom appeared to be homeless.

Jordy Smith said the ordeal began in the City Heights neighborhood more than two years ago. After breaking her hip, she temporarily left the house and asked the man, whom she believed to be a plumber, to make repairs. While she was away, she says, he locked her out.

“He just took over and, like, before we knew it, there was like 15 people,” Smith said.

Smith later discovered that the man was not a licensed plumber. She also said he had moved the utility accounts into his own name and started renting rooms to other people.

The group living at the property reportedly grew over time. Boats and recreational vehicles arrived, and people were allegedly charged to stay in rooms or park their RVs there. Smith and her partner said they were unable to get inside their own home. When they tried to speak with the occupants, the people inside would lock the door and refuse to talk.

“I couldn’t sleep at night. I mean, it just seemed like we’d never get back home,” Smith said.

A property-removal company hired to help said cases like this can be difficult because authorities may treat them as civil landlord-tenant disputes rather than trespassing. Under California law, people who stay on a property continuously for 30 days may gain tenant-at-will protections. In such cases, police may not be able to remove them immediately, and the owner can be required to pursue a formal eviction.

The company’s owner said tenant protections are important, but the process can make it hard to quickly distinguish legitimate tenants from people who have no right to live in a home. He argued that the law should protect renters while giving owners and law enforcement a clear way to address unlawful occupancy.

In August, deputies from the San Diego County Sheriff’s Office confronted the occupants, according to the company. The group said it worked with local authorities and followed the legal process, including an eviction, before the property was returned to Smith.

Smith is urging state officials to change the law, saying the experience caused her and her partner significant stress.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News