Gnome faces financial strain as its community disputes deepen
Gnome, the desktop environment used by Ubuntu, Fedora and other Linux distributions, is one of open source’s most prominent projects. But the nonprofit that supports it is struggling financially. It has slashed its budget by nearly two-thirds, and interim executive director Allan Day has said his optimism was “crushed.” Meanwhile, contributors have spent recent months arguing on Mastodon about Charlie Kirk, a magazine column on masks at a lesbian bar, trans rights and Palestine. This week, the foundation suspended several participants for 10 days.
The dispute reflects a broader tension in open-source technology, where political activism has become a visible part of some communities. Gnome’s troubles stand in contrast to Omarchy, a Linux project led by Ruby on Rails creator David Heinemeier Hansson, known as DHH. He describes its leadership as a “benevolent dictatorship” and says it steers clear of code-of-conduct politics. Omarchy says it merged more than 740 code changes from over 180 contributors in 12 weeks. Its new foundation has also secured pledges of about $23.7 million. Gnome’s foundation, by comparison, budgeted $435,000 for the year.
Gnome’s finances and leadership
Gnome provides the desktop interface—the windows, menus and app launcher—as well as a range of applications. Many people who use Linux on a desktop have used Gnome, even if they didn’t recognize the name. It is the default desktop on distributions including Red Hat Enterprise Linux, Ubuntu, Debian and Fedora Workstation.
The Gnome Foundation, the nonprofit responsible for covering the project’s expenses, came close to running out of money. Its 2023–24 budget anticipated $1.201 million in revenue, including $475,000 in fundraising that never arrived. Its reserves dropped to around $140,000, prompting the organization to cut spending.
The foundation’s 2025–26 budget projected income of $435,000, enough to pay for three full-time staff members. The board described the organization as being in a “sustainable financial position.” That may be technically accurate, though the budget leaves little room to maneuver.
Leadership has also been unsettled. Gnome’s last permanent executive director resigned in August 2025, just four months into the role. Then-board president Allan Day took over. In June, he withdrew from a board election, saying that infighting, personal accusations and deliberate misinformation had crushed his optimism. The board later appointed him interim executive director.
An Atlantic column sets off a community dispute
On Sept. 26, longtime Gnome developer Nirbheek Chauhan, who serves on the foundation’s membership committee, shared Helen Lewis’s Atlantic column, “How to Destroy a Lesbian Bar.” The article discussed a Massachusetts bar that faced criticism after making Saturday nights mask-optional. Critics reportedly called the decision a “mass disabling event” and compared the bar to fascists.
Chauhan wrote that the column was a useful read for anyone wondering why participating in the Gnome community could feel so exhausting. The response that followed seemed to illustrate his point.
A Mastodon user called Victoria asked whether Chauhan was the same person who had argued that Charlie Kirk should be part of the Gnome community. When asked for examples, she also accused him of defending Framework, a modular-laptop company, for supporting white supremacists. Framework had sponsored Hyprland, the software used by DHH’s Linux project. Gnome’s first vice president later said Chauhan had not raised Kirk in the discussion.
About 10 minutes later, another user, Alice, said she had archived the post and pages showing who had liked or boosted it, in order to preserve the evidence. GStreamer developer Sebastian Dröge objected to compiling lists of people. Gnome contributor Adrien Plazas replied that, for many people facing multiple forms of marginalization, keeping lists could be a matter of literal life and death.
On Oct. 5, foundation President Sri Ramkrishna said the organization would draw a line at personal attacks, shaming, dehumanizing language and intimidation. Two days later, Day and the executive committee apologized, saying the statement had not met the foundation’s own standards for inclusion.
Suspensions followed on Monday. Hari Rana posted a notice saying he had called another member a “coward” for blocking him on Mastodon and had described others as “victim blamers.” A commenter identified Alice and Victoria as the other two people suspended. Day described the 10-day suspensions as “a short time-out for people to reflect.”
Some critics argued that the suspensions themselves were oppressive. Gnome’s code of conduct says that criticizing oppressive behavior is not a violation simply because the criticism is delivered in a tone others dislike. Plazas argued that expecting people to remain calm while confronting systemic oppression can itself be an oppressive stance. The same section of the code also protects telling someone to “go away”—the kind of response the blocked member had given.
Developer Jordan Petridis said the Gnome community he knew stood for accessibility, inclusion, diversity, trans rights and a Free Palestine. His conclusion was blunt: “This institution is rotten to its core.”
Omarchy keeps moving
DHH has taken a different approach to conduct rules. In September 2025, he described Tommy Robinson’s London rally as a “powerful march” and wrote that a “demographic nightmare” had already “enveloped London.”
Omarchy is a ready-to-use Linux setup built on Hyprland, the same software that led to accusations that Framework was supporting the far right. On Nov. 4, DHH announced Omarchy version 4.5, saying the project had merged more than 740 pull requests from over 180 contributors in 12 weeks. On Tuesday, the day Gnome’s suspensions took effect, he merged a change replacing Gnome’s file browser with Omarchy’s own.
The new Omacom Foundation has received pledges totaling roughly $23.7 million. That includes contributions of $1 million each from 12 founding patrons, among them Shopify CEO Tobi Lütke and DHH. A single pledge of that size exceeds twice the amount Gnome’s foundation expected to bring in over the whole of last year.
Omarchy’s stated principles reject what they call code-of-conduct “struggle sessions” and “identity-overload nonsense” in open source. The project says it is not a democracy, but a “benevolent dictatorship” in the tradition of Linux, Ruby and Rails.
In September, Day wrote that Gnome’s year-end fundraising drive would be essential to the foundation’s ability to grow and support the project. The organization’s financial position remains precarious, and the community’s internal disputes have added another challenge.




