California Gubernatorial Debate Highlights Healthcare for Undocumented Immigrants

During a recent gubernatorial debate in California, all Democratic candidates expressed their support for providing health care to undocumented immigrants. This stance came even after lengthy discussions about the already high costs of the state’s health care system, which many argue burdens families, businesses, and the state budget.

Tom Steyer, a billionaire businessman and Democratic candidate, noted the faults in the immigration system, suggesting it negatively impacts those working and living in California. This remark followed the current governor’s decision to cut reparations for undocumented immigrants as a move to combat the growing budget deficit.

Former Congresswoman Katie Porter addressed concerns regarding the expenses associated with offering free health care to undocumented individuals. When asked about the potential costs, she stated, “We can’t have sick people who are making other people sick.” Her Republican opponent, Sheriff Chad Bianco, quickly replied, “They shouldn’t be here,” leaving Porter momentarily taken aback.

“If everyone doesn’t have access to care, if we don’t get vaccinated, the rest of us are at risk,” she continued, emphasizing the complications created when undocumented individuals skip regular doctor visits and rely on emergency services.

Xavier Becerra, another Democratic contender and former Health and Human Services Secretary under Biden, claimed that immigrants, whether documented or not, contribute to society and sometimes require medical care for on-the-job injuries. He argued that it is unwise to leave families without access to necessary health care services, which can ultimately lead to far costlier emergency room visits.

The remaining Democratic candidates, San Jose Mayor Matt Mahan and former Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, did not directly address the issue of providing health care to undocumented immigrants during the debate.

In contrast, Republican candidate Steve Hilton remarked that the focus should be on the billions spent on health care for those living in the country illegally, asserting that it’s a waste of resources. He stated that addressing the issue starts with cutting funding for those who shouldn’t be in the country in the first place.

Bianco added, “When are we going to draw the line on other crimes? That’s illegal.” He emphasized not encouraging illegal immigration, suggesting that it takes resources away from legal residents.

Prior to advocating for taxpayer-funded health care access for undocumented immigrants, several Democratic candidates engaged in discussions about their support for government-run health care. Steyer openly supported a single-payer plan, while Becerra mentioned that California should aim to implement Medicare for All. Porter pressed Becerra for clearer answers, seeking confirmation on the proposal for a state-level single-payer system.

However, acknowledging the financial implications has led to discussions about the sustainability of such plans. Steyer cautioned that the costs are significantly taxing budgets, while Villaraigosa projected a $500 billion price tag for a state-run system, indicating the need for federal approval for such an initiative. “It’s pie in the sky,” he remarked.